The episode begins in the past, with John receiving a phone call that their children were switched. It's an alternate reality.

They found out after Daphne had already gotten meningitis.

Regina is grilled on the stand.

The judge awards custody of Dapne to the Kennishes.

They show Daphne as being able to talk, but not to hear at all when she arrives at her new home.

Daphne has a cochlear implant and speaks perfectly.

Bay is a good student trying to get extra credits to graduate school early.

Daphne uses her deafness and being "lost" for the first 3 years of her life to get everything from the Kennishes.

Daphne is best friends with Simone.

Bay meets Emmett after being dumped by Daphne at a party.

When Daphne is too stupid to catch a guy with conversation, she uses sex.

Kathryn is having an affair.

The Kennish family never learned ASL

Daphne spends the night learning ASL to engage with Emmett.

Emmett helps Bay find information on her birth mother.

John was the one who decided not to put Daphne in a "deaf bubble" by learning ASL.

Bay and Daphne go to meet Regina.

Adriana breaks the news that Regina killed herself on their birthday.

John has a heart attack and Regina isn't there to save him.

John wakes up.