Wanting to spend more time with the new warehouse worker Matt, Oscar asks Darryl to organize a happy hour outing between the office employees and the warehouse workers.
Jim invites his wife Pam, who is unusually excited to see everyone.
They invite a friend of hers, Julie, to meet with Michael. Julie seems to take a liking to Michael as she laughs at everything he says, but when Michael learns they invited Julie for him, he changes his outfit and starts acting oddly.
He causes a scene to the point where the female manager threatens to throw him out. Michael initially stands down, but then decides to confront her about what happened. The two end up hitting it off and she offers him a free lunch at the bar. Julie notices this and leaves.
Meanwhile, Andy and Erin do their best to keep their relationship under wraps because they don't want to deal with relationship drama.
They first try to keep their distance from each other. They then attempt to flirt with other bar patrons, but when Erin takes the flirting too far, they end up having an argument in the photo booth.
Realizing that hiding their relationship has caused too much drama, Andy publicly announces their relationship through the intercom.
Dwight rethinks his pre-natal contract with Angela when Isabel arrives at the bar.
Dwight and Isabel have fun playing Whack-A-Mole together while Angela tries to get in on the fun. Dwight thinks that Isabel would be better suited to have his children, so he tells Angela he is canceling the contract, prompting Angela to get a summons.
When she confronts Dwight about the contract in front of Isabel, Isabel "whacks" Angela on the head and scares her off. Dwight gives her a passionate kiss afterward.
Oscar is upset that Matt didn't show up with the rest of them, prompting Darryl to tell Oscar that they have nothing in common, but when Matt finally shows up, Oscar gets excited and the two shoot hoops together.
At the end of the episode, Darryl asks the Japanese warehouse worker Hide to recount his story about how he used to be a heart surgeon and how he failed a heart operation on a Yakuza boss, prompting him to flee to the United States, where Darryl gave him a job.
However, he claims that he failed that heart operation on purpose.