Grey's Anatomy Review: Time For Goodbyes... Comments (Page 2)
157 Comments
marsha
November 22nd, 2011 7:31 PM
I loved the Dark Was The Night episode but i got to tell you that the rest of the season has been mediocre at best, and yes I have been a steadfast fan from the beginning. But after last season I'm not sure how long I will remain a diehard follower. I can not believe the show is on hiatus yet again. I mean do these people ever not take a break?!? With all these breaks and last seasons reruns my friends and I aren't worried about nearly breaking our necks to catch the next episode because we can always catch a rerun since there sure was plenty of them last fall. Come on Shondra, GA is steady losing it's momentum. Pull some new tricks out of your bag and keep us fans dying to see the next episode every week like it use to be, before last season that is.
Twhite
November 21st, 2011 10:08 PM
I enjoyed the drama -no singing a bonus. Love seeing der-mer "close" again...who knows?
Massi
November 19th, 2011 10:45 PM
Waiting for January?? Too long!!! Henry died too soon. They should have left him until the end of the season...
shashya Rank: New User
November 19th, 2011 5:50 AM
its quite amazing how such a powerful story line touches our heart...other screen writers should seriously learn for shonda
Jasmine
November 18th, 2011 10:31 AM
might teddy be pregnant? Then there would be a part of henry left afterall...
Kimberly
November 17th, 2011 9:37 PM
I think teddy will end up going crazy on Owen for him not telling her and then on Cristina ... I also think Cristina is going to go to have a small effect as well and be upset they never told her who it was..As for Meredith and Derek I am truly hoping she has his baby even though they told her she has angry ovaries. Her having a baby with him that would make my year xD .. Also Cristina and Preston Burke were a better couple to me ..
teresa
November 16th, 2011 1:13 AM
I reviewed all posters ,most fans are agree with s8p09's great, but no one gave the credit to director& writer, allow me to introduce them
Director Mr.Allison Liddi-Brown who directed s6p6: I saw what I saw.......
Writer Debora Cahn who wrote s7p22 final:Unaccompanied Minor......
Sue
November 15th, 2011 7:56 PM
Very HAPPY that they aint getting zola, thank god for small favors, maybe then they can get back to a storyline that is good and fitted for them.
Amanda Freeman
November 15th, 2011 2:06 PM
Ok the one night that it is a midterm finale. I did not watch it. I know not a very good fan. What I have read is exciting. Teddy- I cannot wait to see her reaction she is going to be devistated. Merder- not getting Zola is sad I think something else will work out. The preview that I saw with Alex and Mer in the ambulance with a baby, I was scared that the whole thing was going to blow up. I cannot wait Untl January to see what happens. I won't miss another episode... Seriously....
rs
November 15th, 2011 1:54 PM
Almost great epi...1st scene-the 3 original interns at Joe's-can't get much better than that. Mer/Alex scenes...just wow! Mer/Cris, Der/Cris, Mer/Der, Der/Mark scenes--vintage Grey's. I say "almost" great because wayyyyy too much teddy! Even Henry couldn't save a teddy scene. She is FF material for me. I don't care how she reacts; we all know it will be over-acted. But I am interested in seeing how Cristina reacts to not knowing it was Henry...watch out Owen. Bonus: Very little april!
patriziasaltarelli
November 14th, 2011 3:27 AM
mi scuso per aver inavvertitamente inviato il commento due volte e visto che ci sono vi dico che la pausa a me sembrerà più breve perchè dal 30 di novembre verranno trasmessi gli episodi doppiati in italiano.Alleluia!
patriziasaltarelli
November 14th, 2011 3:12 AM
sono sincera guardo grey's anatomy soprattutto per Merder,potrebbero anche elencare gli ingredienti di una ricetta li amerei lo stesso ,tuttavia ci sono alcune cose che mi lasciano perplessa :Meredith prova a rimanere incinta.segue una cura per la fertilità che le dà problemi alla vista,bene,a qualsiasi medico verrebbe l'idea di sostituire il farmaco con un altro che non abbia effetti collaterali,ma qui nel tempio della medicina questo non avviene,provare con l'inseminazione assistita?neanche a pensarci!invece in PP una Addison (che trovo patetica )si sottopone alle sperimentazioni più avanzate per avere un figlio,questo mi fà proprio arrabbiare d'accordo il dramma ,lo spettacolo e quant'altro ma forse passiamo troppo per cretini
patriziasaltarelli
November 14th, 2011 3:09 AM
sono sincera guardo grey's anatomy soprattutto per Merder,potrebbero anche elencare gli ingredienti di una ricetta li amerei lo stesso ,tuttavia ci sono alcune cose che mi lasciano perplessa :Meredith prova a rimanere incinta.segue una cura per la fertilità che le dà problemi alla vista,bene,a qualsiasi medico verrebbe l'idea di sostituire il farmaco con un altro che non abbia effetti collaterali,ma qui nel tempio della medicina questo non avviene,provare con l'inseminazione assistita?neanche a pensarci!invece in PP una Addison (che trovo patetica )si sottopone alle sperimentazioni più avanzate per avere un figlio,questo mi fà proprio arrabbiare d'accordo il dramma ,lo spettacolo e quant'altro ma forse passiamo troppo per cretini
CountryGirl024
November 14th, 2011 2:49 AM
Does anyone know the title to the song that was playing
right after the death of Christine's surgery on Henry?
Some of the words were
She went quietly without a word... she wrote the note
chose to walk away...
Please respond if you know.
Thanks
Country Girl
Billie
November 14th, 2011 2:49 AM
Truly I think Meredith and Derek are what make the show. Are they perfect characters? No, but if they were what would be the point in watching? As for the many cliffhangers...yes these are aggravating but mostly because I can hardly stand the waiting to see what happens. Having Christina do the surgery without knowing who she was working on...well yes that is definitely a Christina moment (even if real life would not even dream of this). However if you do not like Meredith and Derek...why are you even watching the show? This show has ALWAYS been centered on these two. I have seen every episode and they are the central characters, don't like them? Don't watch. Finally...seeing Derek finally remember that Meredith is not all to blame for the Zoe fiasco was long awaited. If I recall correctly she is the one who took the baby home when he would not answer his phone for a very long time. Not answering the phone was immature and frankly in real life that is the moment something ter
Peg
November 14th, 2011 2:10 AM
Didn't love this one, tho I do look forward to resolution of it in Jan. Brilliant moment when Christina finds out whose time of death she just called. I concur with the poster who misses George and Izzy. Great characters, warm (G) and fiesty (I). I was heartbroken when George was killed off... why not just ship him overseas, so we might at least get a visit...I've fantasized about a ghost or dream-visitor, but this just isn't the show for that.
Re: mcbabies:For me, there need to be babies and kids on the show, for the characters to grow like real people do. Perpetual adolescense is boring. We don't need to see much of these offsproings, but we DO need to see how they challenge and expand the hearts of our fictional friends.
Re: McSteamy: I love his estrogen-soaked mellowness; in context of the character's arc, it's hilarious.
Re: McDreamy: I hated the grumpy McDreamy of the previous episodes. If we lose Patrick Dempsey, and the quiet centre of the show that is the Mer-D
aussie
November 14th, 2011 1:56 AM
@daphne all i said was MAYBE they are watching Zola in the living room, it is only my opinion. I was trying to put 2 and 5 together and guessing.
Yes the episode is entitled "This Magic Moment" don't you think it would be magic if they did have Zola back?
Also i would really love for Mer to be pregnant as well a little more magic 2 for the price of 1.
@Sofia agree there were a lot of clues in the episode pointing towards them eventually having a child of there own, moving into the dreamhouse and living happily, good to see Derek admit it was just as much his fault and he can't live without Meredith.
We all know ABC intend to continue with Grey's i'm hoping at least another 2 years which will bring it to 10 years and hopefully Ellen and Patrick will sign for another 2 ASAP. They are renegotiating currently!
C
November 13th, 2011 8:11 PM
i want meredith to have a baby, first to piss all of you off, and two, why the hell not? i dont think it would be weird. we need some new stuff here people. crazy surgeries and deaths aren't cutting it anymore. and seriously, enough with all these unnecessary deaths. i honestly like this cast more though. but STOP KILLING PEOPLE and stop changing the cast. i dont want any more replacements. the cardiac surgeon has already been replaced at least three times, so has addisons former position. SERIOUSLY cut the crap. Lexie is awesome. no surrogates. Nicky if you hate meredith and derek together so much, do us all a favor and stop watching the show. Derek and addison did not have any chemistry whatsoever.
Poor Henry:( I really liked him! He brought life to Teddy, and he was quite awesome.
Merder not getting Zola... I really don't mind actually.
Last scene with Alex and Mer. I was very surprised. I was definitely not expecting that.
Jan L
November 13th, 2011 3:51 PM
Worst episode of Grey's ever! Ajmmed in a zillion cliff hangers. So liitle faith in the loyalty of viewers? There's no longer even a semblance of medical accuracy in Grey's. Pure manipulation! I never expected 100% medical accuracy, but at this point, I find the manipulation indicative of an underlying attitude that disrespects viewers. The whole noenatal transprt arc was utter nonsense. 5th yr surgical residents sent to transport a neonate -- even one with a TE fistula. Done solely to create another cliffhanger. Next, what surgeon operates w/o a review of the chart, labs, etc? Silly, silly, silly. So much wrong here.... Very, very sad!
Jessica
November 13th, 2011 1:21 PM
Correction she is appearing in epi #9and 10
Jessica
November 13th, 2011 1:18 PM
I think it was a family that hit the ambulance. This site says Stella Maeve (sp?) Will be appearing in two episodes this season #10 and #11 after coming to the hospital from a serious car accident with minor injuries and her family in serious condition. Wouldn't that make sense that she is a vcitim from the cliffhanger? I think so. I. Have paused that scene a couple times and the "back up" ambulance seems possible, I'm leaning towards this scenario.
junsu
November 13th, 2011 12:00 PM
c'mon people, meredith having a surrogate (whoever that would be but especially as cristina or lexie) would be a TERRIBLE and LAME idea! geez, im surprised you can even consider it... that wouldn't be lovely, that would just be stupid. storyline about meredith having a baby would be boring anyway.. if they stop with the greys and meredith gets pregnant or adopts someone or whatever that would be ok but i personally wouldn't wanna see her raising a kid in the show, even though i like mer der together a lot and think they deserve a kid but even baby sophia freaked me out a bit (maybe kids just freak me out? could be) but now that i don't see her very much and don't hear from her very much it's cool. but to me, her existence is still weird and unnecessary. i mean why make callie pregnant and mark the father? just lame. but thats the way it is. and if they did that with merder baby too (the "baby does exist but we never show him/her on the show") would be weird. so please, no baby! mer
nicky
November 13th, 2011 8:27 AM
First of all, I hate Mer and Der. Together I mean. I did from the start. He was much better with Addie, and I would see him with ANYONE, but her. They are annoying to me. Maybe because Mer is annoying to no end.
I'm glad they are not getting Zola, because Mer doesn't deserve her after her stunt. It doesn't matter why she did what she did. The point is that she makes decisions without thinking about consequences and without considering others. That's not a mother material. I would love for Derek to just leaveher and get Zola to raise on his own. He is the one who truly wanted her from the start.
Killing off Henry was just dumb. Heartbreaking and very well played though.
Kim (The Netherlands)
November 13th, 2011 7:17 AM
Question? The car that hit the ambulance Mer en Alex were in.. didn't it look like an ambulance, that was suppose to be on the way? I can't really tell. But that would suck, right. Talk about having a bad day!
Meredith: People change, but they don't change.
November 22nd, 2011 7:31 PM
I loved the Dark Was The Night episode but i got to tell you that the rest of the season has been mediocre at best, and yes I have been a steadfast fan from the beginning. But after last season I'm not sure how long I will remain a diehard follower. I can not believe the show is on hiatus yet again. I mean do these people ever not take a break?!? With all these breaks and last seasons reruns my friends and I aren't worried about nearly breaking our necks to catch the next episode because we can always catch a rerun since there sure was plenty of them last fall. Come on Shondra, GA is steady losing it's momentum. Pull some new tricks out of your bag and keep us fans dying to see the next episode every week like it use to be, before last season that is.
November 21st, 2011 10:08 PM
I enjoyed the drama -no singing a bonus. Love seeing der-mer "close" again...who knows?
November 19th, 2011 10:45 PM
Waiting for January?? Too long!!! Henry died too soon. They should have left him until the end of the season...
Rank: New User
November 19th, 2011 5:50 AM
its quite amazing how such a powerful story line touches our heart...other screen writers should seriously learn for shonda
November 18th, 2011 10:31 AM
might teddy be pregnant? Then there would be a part of henry left afterall...
November 17th, 2011 9:37 PM
I think teddy will end up going crazy on Owen for him not telling her and then on Cristina ... I also think Cristina is going to go to have a small effect as well and be upset they never told her who it was..As for Meredith and Derek I am truly hoping she has his baby even though they told her she has angry ovaries. Her having a baby with him that would make my year xD .. Also Cristina and Preston Burke were a better couple to me ..
November 16th, 2011 1:13 AM
I reviewed all posters ,most fans are agree with s8p09's great, but no one gave the credit to director& writer, allow me to introduce them
Director Mr.Allison Liddi-Brown who directed s6p6: I saw what I saw.......
Writer Debora Cahn who wrote s7p22 final:Unaccompanied Minor......
November 15th, 2011 7:56 PM
Very HAPPY that they aint getting zola, thank god for small favors, maybe then they can get back to a storyline that is good and fitted for them.
November 15th, 2011 2:06 PM
Ok the one night that it is a midterm finale. I did not watch it. I know not a very good fan. What I have read is exciting. Teddy- I cannot wait to see her reaction she is going to be devistated. Merder- not getting Zola is sad I think something else will work out. The preview that I saw with Alex and Mer in the ambulance with a baby, I was scared that the whole thing was going to blow up. I cannot wait Untl January to see what happens. I won't miss another episode... Seriously....
November 15th, 2011 1:54 PM
Almost great epi...1st scene-the 3 original interns at Joe's-can't get much better than that. Mer/Alex scenes...just wow! Mer/Cris, Der/Cris, Mer/Der, Der/Mark scenes--vintage Grey's. I say "almost" great because wayyyyy too much teddy! Even Henry couldn't save a teddy scene. She is FF material for me. I don't care how she reacts; we all know it will be over-acted. But I am interested in seeing how Cristina reacts to not knowing it was Henry...watch out Owen. Bonus: Very little april!
November 14th, 2011 3:27 AM
mi scuso per aver inavvertitamente inviato il commento due volte e visto che ci sono vi dico che la pausa a me sembrerà più breve perchè dal 30 di novembre verranno trasmessi gli episodi doppiati in italiano.Alleluia!
November 14th, 2011 3:12 AM
sono sincera guardo grey's anatomy soprattutto per Merder,potrebbero anche elencare gli ingredienti di una ricetta li amerei lo stesso ,tuttavia ci sono alcune cose che mi lasciano perplessa :Meredith prova a rimanere incinta.segue una cura per la fertilità che le dà problemi alla vista,bene,a qualsiasi medico verrebbe l'idea di sostituire il farmaco con un altro che non abbia effetti collaterali,ma qui nel tempio della medicina questo non avviene,provare con l'inseminazione assistita?neanche a pensarci!invece in PP una Addison (che trovo patetica )si sottopone alle sperimentazioni più avanzate per avere un figlio,questo mi fà proprio arrabbiare d'accordo il dramma ,lo spettacolo e quant'altro ma forse passiamo troppo per cretini
November 14th, 2011 3:09 AM
sono sincera guardo grey's anatomy soprattutto per Merder,potrebbero anche elencare gli ingredienti di una ricetta li amerei lo stesso ,tuttavia ci sono alcune cose che mi lasciano perplessa :Meredith prova a rimanere incinta.segue una cura per la fertilità che le dà problemi alla vista,bene,a qualsiasi medico verrebbe l'idea di sostituire il farmaco con un altro che non abbia effetti collaterali,ma qui nel tempio della medicina questo non avviene,provare con l'inseminazione assistita?neanche a pensarci!invece in PP una Addison (che trovo patetica )si sottopone alle sperimentazioni più avanzate per avere un figlio,questo mi fà proprio arrabbiare d'accordo il dramma ,lo spettacolo e quant'altro ma forse passiamo troppo per cretini
November 14th, 2011 2:49 AM
Does anyone know the title to the song that was playing
right after the death of Christine's surgery on Henry?
Some of the words were
She went quietly without a word... she wrote the note
chose to walk away...
Please respond if you know.
Thanks
Country Girl
November 14th, 2011 2:49 AM
Truly I think Meredith and Derek are what make the show. Are they perfect characters? No, but if they were what would be the point in watching? As for the many cliffhangers...yes these are aggravating but mostly because I can hardly stand the waiting to see what happens. Having Christina do the surgery without knowing who she was working on...well yes that is definitely a Christina moment (even if real life would not even dream of this). However if you do not like Meredith and Derek...why are you even watching the show? This show has ALWAYS been centered on these two. I have seen every episode and they are the central characters, don't like them? Don't watch. Finally...seeing Derek finally remember that Meredith is not all to blame for the Zoe fiasco was long awaited. If I recall correctly she is the one who took the baby home when he would not answer his phone for a very long time. Not answering the phone was immature and frankly in real life that is the moment something ter
November 14th, 2011 2:10 AM
Didn't love this one, tho I do look forward to resolution of it in Jan. Brilliant moment when Christina finds out whose time of death she just called. I concur with the poster who misses George and Izzy. Great characters, warm (G) and fiesty (I). I was heartbroken when George was killed off... why not just ship him overseas, so we might at least get a visit...I've fantasized about a ghost or dream-visitor, but this just isn't the show for that.
Re: mcbabies:For me, there need to be babies and kids on the show, for the characters to grow like real people do. Perpetual adolescense is boring. We don't need to see much of these offsproings, but we DO need to see how they challenge and expand the hearts of our fictional friends.
Re: McSteamy: I love his estrogen-soaked mellowness; in context of the character's arc, it's hilarious.
Re: McDreamy: I hated the grumpy McDreamy of the previous episodes. If we lose Patrick Dempsey, and the quiet centre of the show that is the Mer-D
November 14th, 2011 1:56 AM
@daphne all i said was MAYBE they are watching Zola in the living room, it is only my opinion. I was trying to put 2 and 5 together and guessing.
Yes the episode is entitled "This Magic Moment" don't you think it would be magic if they did have Zola back?
Also i would really love for Mer to be pregnant as well a little more magic 2 for the price of 1.
@Sofia agree there were a lot of clues in the episode pointing towards them eventually having a child of there own, moving into the dreamhouse and living happily, good to see Derek admit it was just as much his fault and he can't live without Meredith.
We all know ABC intend to continue with Grey's i'm hoping at least another 2 years which will bring it to 10 years and hopefully Ellen and Patrick will sign for another 2 ASAP. They are renegotiating currently!
November 13th, 2011 8:11 PM
i want meredith to have a baby, first to piss all of you off, and two, why the hell not? i dont think it would be weird. we need some new stuff here people. crazy surgeries and deaths aren't cutting it anymore. and seriously, enough with all these unnecessary deaths. i honestly like this cast more though. but STOP KILLING PEOPLE and stop changing the cast. i dont want any more replacements. the cardiac surgeon has already been replaced at least three times, so has addisons former position. SERIOUSLY cut the crap. Lexie is awesome. no surrogates. Nicky if you hate meredith and derek together so much, do us all a favor and stop watching the show. Derek and addison did not have any chemistry whatsoever.
Rank: Guest Star
November 13th, 2011 6:37 PM
Poor Henry:( I really liked him! He brought life to Teddy, and he was quite awesome.
Merder not getting Zola... I really don't mind actually.
Last scene with Alex and Mer. I was very surprised. I was definitely not expecting that.
November 13th, 2011 3:51 PM
Worst episode of Grey's ever! Ajmmed in a zillion cliff hangers. So liitle faith in the loyalty of viewers? There's no longer even a semblance of medical accuracy in Grey's. Pure manipulation! I never expected 100% medical accuracy, but at this point, I find the manipulation indicative of an underlying attitude that disrespects viewers. The whole noenatal transprt arc was utter nonsense. 5th yr surgical residents sent to transport a neonate -- even one with a TE fistula. Done solely to create another cliffhanger. Next, what surgeon operates w/o a review of the chart, labs, etc? Silly, silly, silly. So much wrong here.... Very, very sad!
November 13th, 2011 1:21 PM
Correction she is appearing in epi #9and 10
November 13th, 2011 1:18 PM
I think it was a family that hit the ambulance. This site says Stella Maeve (sp?) Will be appearing in two episodes this season #10 and #11 after coming to the hospital from a serious car accident with minor injuries and her family in serious condition. Wouldn't that make sense that she is a vcitim from the cliffhanger? I think so. I. Have paused that scene a couple times and the "back up" ambulance seems possible, I'm leaning towards this scenario.
November 13th, 2011 12:00 PM
c'mon people, meredith having a surrogate (whoever that would be but especially as cristina or lexie) would be a TERRIBLE and LAME idea! geez, im surprised you can even consider it... that wouldn't be lovely, that would just be stupid. storyline about meredith having a baby would be boring anyway.. if they stop with the greys and meredith gets pregnant or adopts someone or whatever that would be ok but i personally wouldn't wanna see her raising a kid in the show, even though i like mer der together a lot and think they deserve a kid but even baby sophia freaked me out a bit (maybe kids just freak me out? could be) but now that i don't see her very much and don't hear from her very much it's cool. but to me, her existence is still weird and unnecessary. i mean why make callie pregnant and mark the father? just lame. but thats the way it is. and if they did that with merder baby too (the "baby does exist but we never show him/her on the show") would be weird. so please, no baby! mer
November 13th, 2011 8:27 AM
First of all, I hate Mer and Der. Together I mean. I did from the start. He was much better with Addie, and I would see him with ANYONE, but her. They are annoying to me. Maybe because Mer is annoying to no end.
I'm glad they are not getting Zola, because Mer doesn't deserve her after her stunt. It doesn't matter why she did what she did. The point is that she makes decisions without thinking about consequences and without considering others. That's not a mother material. I would love for Derek to just leaveher and get Zola to raise on his own. He is the one who truly wanted her from the start.
Killing off Henry was just dumb. Heartbreaking and very well played though.
November 13th, 2011 7:17 AM
Question? The car that hit the ambulance Mer en Alex were in.. didn't it look like an ambulance, that was suppose to be on the way? I can't really tell. But that would suck, right. Talk about having a bad day!