Downton Abbey Review: Almost Normal

at . Comments

If there's one thing I learned on Downton Abbey this week, it is that even during a world war - in a massive country house masquerading as an officer's convalescent hospital, with friends and relatives behind enemy lines - things can become a bit mundane.

Despite multiple small scandals, lost soldiers, a concert and the rather triumphant return of Mr. Bates, there was nothing to really sing about in this episode. The very best bits came, as they almost always do, as quips from the lips of Violet. For those, please visit our section of quotes, as she was on fire once again. What I wouldn't give for someone to whisper in my ear the witty comebacks she expels during regular conversation.

Maggie Smith on Downton Abbey

Lady Grantham finally got her way and Isobel left Downton Abbey to work elsewhere. She had medical knowledge she can share and wanted to be of use. Cora clearly had no desire to include her in the running of the Abbey, despite her outward appearance to the contrary. I hope that doesn't last long, because I enjoyed Isobel and the way she tried so determinedly to be appreciated. She deserved more than she received at the hands of Cora.

With Isobel's departure, her staff was left with little to do in an empty house. Mr. Mosley offered his services to the Abbey with the hopes of becoming Robert's valet and Mrs. Bird started a soup kitchen. Isobel would most certainly approve of their willingness to help during the war, even if they were doing it in her home without her permission. I was pleasantly surprised that Mrs. O'Brien's plan to throw the staff to the streets was not upheld by Cora. Instead, Lady Grantham offered to pay for the food used in the kitchen with household money and to assist when she could.

As Mr. Mosley's hopes of rising in the household ranks were dashed with the reappearance of Mr. Bates, everyone else in the house rejoiced at his return. Most especially Anna, as any chance to rekindle their blossoming romance brings happiness to them both. Once again, Mrs. Hughes tried to frighten Bates by tossing around Thomas' new position, but those two are close to becoming the household joke.

Thomas loves to talk about how special he is since he returned to the Abbey as something other than a servant. If it's such a swell gig, then why does he spent 95% of his time fraternizing with the servants he purports to abhor and sitting in their kitchen? I've seen none of the other hospital staff in the servants' kitchen. Perhaps he has been banished from the likes of the professionals for his poor demeanor and insulting ways. It's too bad the servants can't do the same.

Ethel continued her flirtation with the major, and it resulted in her dismissal and pregnancy. I don't know much about World War I, but it would be nice if she got her happy ending and the major decided to marry her. Downton Abbey isn't a romance novel, however, so I fear a darker future awaits her.

Violet's curiosity that Sybil had no beau lead her to believe she was fraternizing with the help. Mary stumbled upon Sybil and Branson in deep discussion shortly thereafter, so Sybil has been outed. Mary promised not to take it further, but the one thing the shedding of this secret did for Sybil was to open her eyes to what might be happening. Branson accused her of being in love with him, and now that she can see if from outside herself, I think she will slowly come to that realization herself.

Finally, Mary's own future was addressed as Mr. Carlisle asked Robert for her hand in marriage. Despite her lingering feelings for Matthew, she thinks it best to accept the proposal. When Matthew and William returned from war during the concert, I had just one more romantic novel wish that Mary would stop her song and run down the aisle and into Matthew's arms. She's far too repressed for that, and they once again just danced around their feelings for one another by talking about their intendeds instead.

Thus is life at the Abbey. They're into a routine and comfortable in their new world. The next big jolt should come when the war ends, the Abbey returns to being only an Abbey and the entire family has to figure out their rightful place in the new world.


Editor Rating: 3.5 / 5.0
  • 3.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.3 / 5.0 (48 Votes)

Carissa Pavlica is the managing editor and a staff writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter and on Google+.


I think it's pretty clear that Matthew and Mary have mutual feelings for each other. This episode was actually one of my favorites of the second series, particularly because I loved Matthew and William returning, and Matthew singing the song with Mary. They have a lot of chemistry. Granted, I've watched the entire second series and the Christmas special (I won't give away any spoilers), but I like the rivalry between Cora and Isobel and the tension that the MIA-storyline provided for a moment.


I did not find this episode mundane at all either. Even if the writers are stretching out the story lines to give us more episodes so be it. I'm enjoying even the minor plots alongside the main ones. I do wish they would show us if Matthew still has any feelings for Mary. But if they get them together the tension of the story wouldn't be very compelling. Having Bates back at Downtown was a interesting development. I wonder what else will happen to keep him and Anna apart. It would be too easy if they got together. I'm sure the writers will make it interesting for us. I'm looking forward to the next episode.


Suzy, you might also tell that to Mrs. O'Brien, who seems to think Thomas can run roughshod over the servants when his responsibilities are limited to overseeing the care of the convalescing soldiers.


While I did feel for Isobel, her big mistake was in considering Downton Abbey a hospital. It is not and never was. DA was always the Crawleys' home first, a portion of which was lent for use as a convalescent *home.* It isn't just a big building the military took over and can use whatever way they like. The major knew that and should have it made it more clear to Isobel that Cora was always in charge of her home. I do like Isobel's spirit, though. Can't keep her down. I do think Daisy is falling for William, although Branson seems more of an excuse for Sybil to live that image of a "reckless spirit." Sybil is a lot of talk, no action while Mary is no talk, no action.


"I'm ready for my next adventure and I don't care who knows it.... I'll get caught in bed with a convalescing soldier, dismissed from my job without a reference or notice, and learn that I'm expecting a baby." Careful what you ask for Ethel!!!!!!


Mrs. O'Brien and Thomas are loathesome! I actually do not see Sybil and Branson together. I was hoping Mary and Matthew would admit their feelings for each other and put an end to the nonsense. And, I found I was actually missing Isobel as I find it amusing that she takes herself so seriously. And, once again, I am a big fan of Lord Grantham; he is a good and kind man. Cora's response to the soup kitchen put a smile on my face. However, why does she let Mrs. O'Brien get away with being so nasty? Does Mrs. Brien really hide it from her that well? Or, is it that Cora really doesn't pay that much attention to "the help?" I love Violet and her pursed lips! This show is so great, I did not find this episode mundane at all.


You have confused Mrs. O'Brien, the ladies maid, with Mrs. Hughes, the head housekeeper.

Tags: ,

Downton Abbey Season 2 Episode 3 Quotes

I'm a woman Mary. I can be as contrary as I choose.


Violet: And this is your beau, is it? A man who lends money and then uses it to blackmail the recipient?
Mary: He lives in a tough world.
Violet: Will you be joining him there?