NCIS Round Table: "The Tell"

at . Comments

Our NCIS review broke down the latest installment of television's #1 show in great detail.

Now, TV Fanatic staff members Steve Marsi, Matt Richenthal and Eric Hochberger have assembled for their weekly Round Table Q&A discussion of events from last week's episode, "The Tell."

Join in below, as we analyze Gibbs, Ryan and much more ...


Describe this episode in one word (or two, or three).

Steve: Entertaining and surprising.

Matt: Strong, albeit a bit erratic.

Eric: A fun ride.

NCIS RT - depreciated -

What was your favorite one-liner from the episode?

Steve: "Get out of my head while you still can."

Matt: "Boss don't bounce."

Eric: "You cant expect someone to keep their feelings all bottled up forever can you?" Or, second place, "I love this woman!" - Ducky as Ryan talked to the body ... priceless.

Best scene?

Steve: I liked the brief Tiva scene at the end. Just because it was Tony and Ziva talking and listening to one another, as friends do, outside the context of overtly teasing us about the future of their relationship.

Matt: The scene in which Ryan labeled DiNozzo a game show host, and how that stuck with him periodically throughout the episode, really got to me. She nailed it and he didn't know how to respond. Also, both scenes in which sailboat drawings were involved. It was nice to see a new layer of Dr. Ryan revealed, whatever you think of her.

Eric: Ryan charming Ducky with her rapport with the deceased, as I said above ... or the unexpected return to the encryption site. As a computer nerd, I'm always a sucker for televised portrayals of them.

Gibbs and Ryan as a couple: Yes or no?

Steve: I enjoyed this episode and seeing the two of them together on the same side (as age-appropriate love interests go, it's hard to top Mark Harmon and Jamie Lee Curtis from a chemistry standpoint), but I don't see it as a long-term romantic fit. Ryan has too much baggage and I don't know if the show needs two Gibbs, as some fans have observed, on a regular basis. Also, her job is based on manipulation and deceit ... not exactly a good sign. I think that if Gibbs were to have a long-term relationship again, he might be better off with someone who's the opposite of Ryan. There will never be another Shannon, but someone who shares her attributes, rather than those of a high-powered government investigator.

Matt: As good a character as she is, I'd prefer seeing her occasionally as an adversary of sorts like we first saw her, ostensibly on the same side (both federal employees) but with a different agenda than Gibbs. The energy is just greater that way. I know romance gets the fan base talking and it's a great to get a taste of it from time to time, but it's not what drives the program.

Eric: I might incur the wrath of some readers, but yes. Who else do you want the man do be with? She's smart and powerful, able to challenge Gibbs while also revealing a more sensitive, vulnerable side. She does have baggage, as Steve says, but so does Gibbs. Both are surprisingly complicated individuals despite their tough exterior. As good a fit as you can find if you ask me.

Michael Weatherly and Sean Astin

What, if anything, was out of place this week?

Steve: I think the case veering off into the typical blackmail realm, with the hacker's true goal being to steal Autec's off-book government funds, felt like two episodes hastily and incongruously condensed into one.

Matt: That Ziva was so caught up with Gibbs and Ryan. I can see it coming from Tony, but something about Ziva's responses felt a bit out of character to me. Also, as Steve and several other readers have put it, the case felt a bit cobbled together around the two characters, as if they struggled a bit to find the right plot with which to advance the Gibbs-Ryan arc.

Eric: Abby not being in more scenes? Just kidding, but seriously, my favorite episodes are written for the team, so to speak, not for the guest stars or one main cast member specifically. I know there's going to be some ebb and flow from week to week and the team members had some great interactions with JLC in this episode, but it lacked for that true team-oriented mojo.

NCIS team MVP of the week?

Steve: Gotta go with the man himself, Leroy Jethro Gibbs, for pegging Wickes as innocent all along. Ryan gets credit for spotting "The Tell," but it wouldn't have been case closed without LJG at the helm.

Matt: McGee. His cyber-warfare skills deserve more screen time.

Eric: Abby. Just because. That's my girl.

Any additional observations?

Steve: Ryan was, originally, slated to work on a case aboard a Navy ship with Gibbs. It will be interesting to see if that means she'll be back at some point in the season finale story arc, which is said to take place in such a setting, or whether her story arc was shifted to the two episodes we've just seen. Either way, I hope we see her again at some point.

Matt: Congratulations to all on the Season 10 picking. Despite all our criticisms, we keep tuning in every week for a reason, and everybody involved with the show gets the thumbs-up overall. Also, Sean Astin was great this week, even if he didn't get a lot of coverage due to JLC.

Eric: Can't wait to see Gibbs and Vance square off again this week. Vance episodes are always intriguing since he keeps his cards close to the vest, and since he's the head of the team but not part of it.

What's your take on these issues of the week on NCIS? Discuss below!

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.


Blachhhh on Jamie Lee Curtis....Pleeeesssseeeee send her far far away...switching channels when she appears...


i hate Jamie Lynn Curtis.
Why in the world would they pick her as love interest for Gibbs??????


Does anyone responsible from NCIS or CBS read these posts? For months now we've been complaining about sub par episodes and the lack of the "team" being together anymore. I can't understand why they won't listen. Had enough of Gibbs and Tiva, let's see some other action. This is my very favorite show and I will never stop watching, I just don't want to feel let down at the end of each show..


I felt that Ryan's conversation with the body was forced, almost playacting. I don't think that she and Gibbs would make a good pair, but I do like the interaction between them as co-workers.
I also like Sean Astin, and would like to see more of him. Iam trying to think of someone who would be good for Gibbs, but it "ain't" happening yet. She would need to be a strong person in her own right, but slightly vulnerable in her private life for some reason that I also haven't been able to think of. Maybe that is why I am not a writer. LOL
I love this show, even though I am a johnny come lately. Didn't start watching until a couple of years ago, and then just had to see them all from the beginning, and now can't wait until the next one. Just as a ha ha, our pastor loves Leroy Jethro Gibbs too, and even used him as a reference in one of her sermons. >G


I think that at the beginning Ziva missed Tony. And then was obsessive about gibbs was a hint she is lonely. Look how upset she got when Tony was ignoring her.


I'm predicting 1)Sean Astin will be back--too big a name not to have a bigger role; 2)JLC will have her own spin-off if it works out here.
I'm observing: 1)I like Gibbs with his mysterious women, they don't have to have a big role... 2)JLC talking to the corpse ala Ducky was NOT a good moment, it felt like she was doing it to manipulate the guys, while when Ducky does it, it seems empathetic with this victim.
It was good to see Gibbs smiling, but I didn't like JLC's character.


I find myself agreeing with most of what you said.
Ziva did seem a little out of character the first part of the show with her reaction to Tony and Gibbs' absence and then in her continued obsessive observation of Gibbs and Ryan.
I can always use a little more Abby but I do think it's good she's rarely the focus of the episodes because, to me, those are often the least successful. She is such a standout character I think it's good we see her only once or twice an episode.
Really liked the interplay between Gibbs and Ryan but do think they would never last romantically. Gibbs is all about trust. Ryan is all about manipulation. Not a match made in Heaven. I really like reading your roundtable discussion every week on new NCIS episodes. Good to see the 3 view points. THANKS


I wanted some clarification on how the team at TV Fanatic choose shows to review and discuss on the round table. i have noticed that some members on the panel also review criminal minds but sadly, they didn't have a review or roundtable last week yet there was an episode.


I really like JLC, but her character as written was unbelievable and manipulative, not a good match for Gibbs.


Why do you keep lauding the Tiva crap? While there is a vocal group of fans that encourage this pairing, there are just as many who hate it and get tired of seeing it shoveled into episodes and commentary.

Tags: ,