Elementary

Thursdays 10:00 PM on CBS
Elementary
TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

Elementary Review: The One Year Coin

by at . Comments

"Dead Man's Switch" revolved around a disturbing case of rape.

But despite the subject matter, this was an enjoyable episode of Elementary due to twists of the case and the backstory of Sherlock and his true sobriety. Obviously, the best aspect was the return of Alfredo and his significant role.

The Blackmailer's Accomplice

I'll talk about the case first: frightening. Gregson came into the conference room in the beginning to meet with Sherlock and his reaction was perfect. He was pissed and disgusted by the video of the young girl being raped. It was played so well and it made me feel the intensity of the case. This wasn't just a murder, it was revolving around three gruesome acts.

Like Sherlock, I enjoyed seeing the rapist beat to hell in jail. Who wouldn't have?!?

While waiting to figure out the identity of the accomplice, I was on the edge of my seat trying to guess that it was someone that we already met. I didn't see the dad being the one behind it all. What a sick man.

In previous Elementary reviews I have praised Alfredo and this episode proved why. He is a really great addition to the show, perfect for Sherlock. When he said, "I know it's hard to do but get over yourself" to Holmes? Exactly. That's all I have to say about that.

The relationship between Joan and Sherlock grows stronger and stronger every week. The latter went from saying that he didn't need to talk about his sobriety with Joan anymore because she wasn't his companion... to at the end of the episode confessing why he doesn't want his sobriety coin. Just another scene of hundreds that prove why these two are just so great together.

That moment was also another great reason why Johnny Lee Miller is such a great actor; Sherlock was shaking and stumbling with his words to tell to Joan the truth about relapsing one day later, and that's all Johnny. He's phenomenal. As is Lucy Lui.

Like I said before, I will go down with this ship! That framed quote of Robert Frosts. Beautiful and perfect. Seemed Sherlock agreed too. They just get each other! It's the best part of the show for me, it makes Elementary what it is.

This episode was a good one all around and next week looks even more intense because Moriarty comes up again. Let the countdown begin!

Review

Editor Rating: 5.0 / 5.0
  • 5.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.8 / 5.0 (58 Votes)
Tags: ,
Avatar

Spectacular show-- love it more every week. Are you hinting that it may be in "trouble"?

Yama1291

Another great episode of Elementary. They actually make you care for the characters without banging you over the head with guilt or drama. Also,
I'm very happy with this show in general. People sometimes unfavourably compare it to the BBC's Sherlock and that is almost always unfounded. Just because the formula is similar, a blatant copy it is not. One can watch either show without diminishing the other.

Avatar

Nice review, but please try to spell the actor's names correctly in a review.

Elementary Season 1 Episode 19 Quotes

It's a small detail but I'm a man of detail and... I just can't accept the coin.

Sherlock

[To Sherlock] I know it's hard but, get over yourself.

Alfredo