Mondays 10:00 PM on ABC
Castle

3747 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Avatar

"based on the immediate information at hand, is it an implausible theory? Anyway, it just helps to illustrate my point that we can never really know what a character is thinking when they do some things."

This, Tonya, is exactly my point. This is the reason why I think it's so important to look at previous episodes and use that info as well.

Let's take something Castle-case related. Let's say the girl who got killed in the season 5 finale was your best friend. You knew her really well. Now you find out she's dead. And apparently she's been spending her time as a hooker. The cops assume she was killed by one of her clients. Based on what you're saying, based on all the facts at hand, like the way she was dressed, sounds coming from her room at all hours of the night, and the fact that you can't really know what someone's thinking, what your friend was thinking at the time, that must mean she really was a hooker right?

Tonya-b

She already pretended that she didn't hear him say that he loved her. Ooohh, then she had an idea. If she told him that her mom's murder caused her to build a wall around her heart and that she could never let a man into her heart until the wall came down, he could probably accept that for now. He wouldn't accept it forever so why not tell him that solving her mom's murder would bring the wall down. That way, he will work hard to help her solve the case and having his sights on the finish line will keep him interested. It's not a perfect plan but at least she gets to keep his close friendship for now.
Now clearly this is a silly theory. But based on the immediate information at hand, is it an implausible theory? Anyway, it just helps to illustrate my point that we can never really know what a character is thinking when they do some things.

Tonya-b

Let me just illustrate with a ridiculous example: Let's pretend that Beckett did not love Castle as a boyfriend and that she just wanted to be friends. She thought he was a lot of fun to have around, he was helpful with cases, and he made her job more fun. She knew that if she told him that she just wanted to be friends that he would quickly lose interest and quit coming around. She didn't want this to happen so she dealt with Castle's advances as they presented. Then when she was shot, Castle blurted out that he loved her. Aye yi yi, what now? She decides to send him away and ignore him for 3 months, since that should cool him off. But she needs his help with her mom's case and she still wants his friendship.

Tonya-b

And lastly, the character can't read the minds of everyone around them and know the reasons and the motivations behind all of their actions, they have to base their decisions on what others tell them, making assumptions that what they are told is the truth, and by observing the behavior of others. So my point here is that it is just unrealistic to say that Castle or Beckett should have done this or that, said what or whatnot, or thought such or such as. It is equally unrealistic to pretend that we know the reasons that the characters did certain things..

Tonya-b

Then, after all the clues are gathered, comparisons to dialogue in other episodes completed, and personal bias is applied to their favorite character, they decide that they know why the character did what they did, said what they said, or acted how they acted. They have also decided what the character should have done, should have said, or should have acted. This just blows my mind because they so easily forgot that the character doesn't get to see the big picture, only what is in front of them. The character doesn't get to ponder dialogue from the past or list multiple possible choices of action and deeply investigate the consequences of each, they get the immediate moment in front of them to say or do something.

Tonya-b

SK, I understand and respect your points of view but, I will once again respectfully suggest that we agree to disagree. I have read thousands and thousands of comments this summer and I find it curious that the vast majority of fans had a negative reaction towards the evil episode and an unfavorable reaction to THF and WS, at least the first time they watched them. But then a lot of people watched them again, over and over, nearly doing a frame by frame analysis to help reveal subtext, hidden clues, double meanings, disguised messages, and other such less than obvious things.

Avatar

Before we all get too worked up about a potential COMPLICATED Season 6, Marlowe has also recently stated that Season 6 will be ROMANTIC! From my point of view, the romance had better be concentrated on Caskett, personally, I have no wish to see Esplanie explored any further, and I certainly have no wish to see anything in relation to Alexis and a new boyfriend. As far as I am concerned, if Alexis never appears in any episode again, it would be fine by me, she adds absolutely nothing to the story as far as I am concerned. This show is also about the Caskett romance, it's about time we saw some!! Going back to a recent post of mine, this show could move forward quickly, if they just had an episode with Caskett having the talk, surely, that time has arrived, for the good of the show.

Tonya-b

SK, it bewilders me a bit how you can say "I think at their worst, they come very close to how actual humans behave at their worst," but then you don't think that the fans should expect serious apologies. When a person treats you with some of their worst behavior, how can we NOT demand an apology? Whenever Castle has EVER treated Beckett badly, he has ALWAYS apologized, profusely. But when Beckett treats Castle badly, we rarely see apologies. We often get convoluted explanations for her behavior but not apologies. That bothers me and I can't help it. Real life demands these apologies, but in TV land they slide by.

Avatar

over 3,000 comments wow!

Avatar

#6 The third one, Castle getting jealous, happens in 5x02, when Beckett gives her card to this guy, Chip in relation to the case and he ends up calling her a bunch of times to ask her out. Castle gets jealous immediately. Beckett got jealous before she and Castle got together, but when they're actually in a relationship, while her general fear that Castle will cheat on her is still there, she's pretty mellow about him going out with miss Swimsuit to throw off paparazzi. She's not happy about it, but there's still that level of trust. If you compare her state of mind, her anxiety level in 5x02 when Castle's on his "date" to Castle's when she's at the Fairwick hotel with Vaughn, the difference is huge. Castle's completely panicked and has no faith whatsoever that Becektt won't sleep with Vaughn. And it's because of his experience with Meredith.

Also, thanks, glad you like my tumblr. :) I love reblogging. What don't you like about it?

Also Goodnight, need sleep -.-




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register