The Mentalist

Sundays 10:00 PM on CBS
The mentalist
TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

The Mentalist Round Table: "Il Tavolo Bianco"

by at .  Updated at . Comments

As if a mob hit, jury tampering, and organ harvesting weren't enough to pack into The Mentalist Season 6 Episode 20, Lisbon was still struggling to make her big decision.

And Jane tried to help her with cannoli this week.

Below, TV Fanatics Robin Harry and Christine Orlando are joined by The Mentalist fan GraceSteph to debate if Daniella is the victim she appears to be, why Lisbon was furious and whether or not PIke realize his competition is Patrick Jane...

The Mentalist Round Table

Is Daniella a victim or does she know more than she's saying about the smuggling ring?

Robin: I didn't get any inkling that she's anything more than a victim.  I figured she was left behind so that the drug harvesting people could pick her up for her organs, while the others were taken to slavery. 

GraceSteph: Good question. I can’t tell whether she is or isn’t. Her appearance at the old house felt somewhat fishy and why was she the only one found in the first place. I’m intrigued to see how this unfolds.

Christine: Robin's right. She could have been left behind for the organ harvesting but it seems odd that it was only her out of all of those girls. And her appearance at the holding house was weird. I'm really not sure but either way, nothing would surprise me on this show. 

Why was Lisbon so furious at Jane for not telling her about Operation Jury Scam?

Robin: I think it was exactly what she said; Lisbon feels that their friendship should keep her from being the target of his cons. She was willing to put her job on the line - yet again - to protect him, only to find out that she was deceived.  Lisbon's at a point in her life where she feels she needs honesty and stability, and Jane leaving her in the dark about the sting disappointed and infuriated her.

GraceSteph: If there’s one thing that attracts Lisbon to Pike is that he appears to (keyword “appears to”) feed into Lisbon’s insecurity on Jane: ambiguous, con, and thoughtless about her feelings. The sting was a reminder to her about this aspect; Jane has had kept her in the dark, hurt and left her many times in the past and he probably always will.

Christine: As close as Lisbon feels to Jane she's never been entirely sure how he feels about her. Leaving her in the dark made her feel like she was no different to any one else and that definitely stung. 

If Jane only wants Lisbon to be happy then why does he look so darn miserable?

Robin: Jane knows there's a very real possibility that her happiness would mean his loneliness. Lisbon is the only one who truly knows Jane, the only one he's allowed to know him, and her departure would leave a giant and likely irreparable hole in his life.

GraceSteph:  It is because he has come into a realization that he loves Lisbon, yet his self-loathing is the con he’s been telling himself that she may be better off with someone else. He gives her the respect to decide her own life just like what she quoted in Green Thumb (“you think you know what’s good for my life”, “it’s my life and I’ll decide what to do with it”) even though that might mean a collapse of his own world.

Christine: Remember, Lisbon was on the short list of things he needed to come back to the states, even if it was only working with her. He absolutely wants her to be happy, even if that's not with him but if he ever got the courage to ask for more he might not look so miserable.

Facing the Grand Jury
Jane must face a grand jury which will decide whether or not he will face charges for the murder of Red John on The Mentalist.

Do  you think Marcus Pike realizes that Patrick Jane is his competition?

Robin: I think he knows on some level, and it had to be a clue that Patrick showed up at Lisbon's door at odd hours of the night with cannoli. Poor guy. I really like Marcus Pike. I almost wish his character was a little less likable so I wouldn't feel as bad for him...but he truly is getting the short end of the stick.

GraceSteph: Yes, him being indirectly pushy about D.C and shadowing Lisbon everywhere are proof to me that he is feeling insecure. He tried so hard to impress Lisbon and I know it is too long to elaborate here but to me he is too manipulative to be called the “super nice guy." He obviously knows Jane’s flaws and has been subtly using it to his advantage.

Christine: I know there's a romance to the whole whirlwind affair but I do feel as though Marcus asking her to move to D.C. is pushy and his "take as much time as you need" super nice guy act is wearing thin. Lisbon isn't very open and that's got to worry him. He'd have to be blind not to see the connection between her and Jane. Nice as he may seem, Marcus Pike is no fool and he's playing this very well.

What was your favorite scene from this Mentalist Season 6 episode?

Robin: Can I pick two?  First is the Jane/Lisbon restaurant scene - it was just so wonderfully awkward, and I loved the delivery of the line, "What DOES a girl want to hear?" Second is at the nightclub when Jane turned on the charm on Brandy.  Good grief, I love flirting Patrick. When he told her he was gonna take her places she never been, I just about hit the floor.

GraceSteph: As much as Jane and Lisbon’s restaurant scene gave me butterflies, I’m going to choose the end scene. Simon and Robin’s phenomenal acting is the one that turn this into one painful-almost-disturbing scene to watch. They did a fantastic job portraying Jane and Lisbon’s suppressed raw emotions and pain through their body language and facial expressions. Jane’s cracking voice and Lisbon finally have tears rolled down her cheek for Jane just scattered my heart into pieces.

Christine: I don't think I can choose. I loved the restaurant scene but it ended far too soon. The final scene was wonderfully awful is there is such a thing. They were both so miserable. I don't doubt that Patrick said what he meant but it certainly wasn't what he felt. And I want to know what Lisbon told Pike when she went back inside with tears in her eyes. 

C. Orlando is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow her on Twitter.

Tags: ,

in the club scene*? srry


anyone knows what was the song that played in the background?


It's episodes like these last few that make me hope more than ever The Mentalist isn't cancelled. I really like the new cast members and everything seems to be fitting together nicely. I think the hard thing for Lisbon is that she knows she loves Jane but she isn't sure if their relationship will ever go further whereas nice-guy is saying that he wants Lisbon permanently in his life. Beautiful acting by both of them in that final scene. Personally, I love the UST between Jane and Lisbon and I'm not wanting to see them hook up as a couple just yet but I definitely don't want to see her leaving.

@ Shallow

Yay - saved by the bell!! But I easily see it being the last. It would be nice if JUST FOR ONCE fan/shippers were rewarded for their patience and a series was completed with the outcome they'd been hoping for from the first episode.


"Jane knows there's a very real possibility that her happiness would mean his loneliness. Lisbon is the only one who truly knows Jane, the only one he's allowed to know him, and her departure would leave a giant and likely irreparable hole in his life." I agree with Robin on this. I feel this is why Jane is looking so miserable. Whether he wants a relationship or not I'm not getting into, but I do feel that he knows that if Lisbon leaves, he will lose the only friend that really understands him or at least tries to, or who really cares about him.


As far as Daniella it could be she was the only girl taken that was a match for someone in need of a heart, but she wasn't kept in very good conditions if they want her heart.
Lisbon was furious for many reasons. Jane didn't tell her what was going on, she thought they had a closer relationship than that now. This Red John thing came back in their lives once again and once again it made him deceive her. She may have been in fear for her own future since she knew where he was going when she helped him get away from Abbott and that might come out in a trial. I could see her being very upset. She watched Jane get cuffed and taken away not knowing when or how she would see him again and right after he said he hoped she would stay. I agree she was left feeling no more important than anyone else also. They used to be partners and his comment when she gave him the socks implied he wanted to continue being partners.
Jane wants Lisbon to be happy but he wishes she could be happy with him and even if not with him at least still in Austin and still working together. He is losing her in two ways that is why he looks miserable.
Does Pike realize that Jane is competition? Without a doubt!! Look at his reaction when he explained the plot of Casablanca to Lisbon. He asked Wylie about Jane and Lisbon's relationship because he could see they were close. And he is always trying to hover around the office, not to be there for her but to come between her and Jane. I wouldn't be surprised if he didn't request this transfer in an attempt to get her away from Jane. I don't like him or trust him and I don't see any chemistry between him and Lisbon.
Favorite scene? Any with just Jane and Lisbon. I loved the look on her face when he said he hoped she would stay. Not that she doesn't already know that but she also needs to hear it.
Come on Jane listen to the song "Can't Fight This Feeling" by Reo Speedwagon. It fits you and Lisbon perfectly and hopefully it will convince you to tell her you love her and want her to stay.


Absolutely NO chemistry between Lisbon and Pike. Why on earth would you settle for a life without passion? You just know when Patrick and Teresa kiss there's gonna be fireworks.....
(Something's hinky about Pike anyhoo)
Oh, how come "Dilca" didn't get modded?????


ksavijaksavijaMy last paych∈ck was $19863 wơrking 17 hours a week online. I've been doing this for almost two years now, mαde over $300k using this syst∈m and it's one amazing additional source of incom∈. It's really user friendly, tasks simple and fun. Just follow the instructions on this page and you can start mαking mon∈y right away.... jump32.c_om


ksavijaksavijaMy last paych∈ck was $19863 wơrking 17 hours a week online. I've been doing this for almost two years now, mαde over $300k using this syst∈m and it's one amazing additional source of incom∈. It's really user friendly, tasks simple and fun. Just follow the instructions on this page and you can start mαking mon∈y right away.... jump32.c_om


I think Jane and Lisbon have too long history to convert their platonic love relationship to romantic one. It is natural that both of them are afraid that they would ruin their super special friendship to being couple. Even so,Lisbon will choose easy life with Pike who appears last some episodes? If it is a real world, women choose romantic life with easy guy is reasonable, but hey, this is a fiction. I want happy ever after (or cute banter ever after ) Jane and Lisbon!


Pike would have to be dense not to sence that there maybe something between Lisbon and Jane, He's just very confident that Lisbon will choose to be with him because he told her that he loves her. I still think that Lisbon will end up with Pike. Either because Jane tells her to go or because he doesn't tell her how he really feels, and she probably won't be truly happy. Which is why I think they may have titled Blue Birds for the irony because a blue bird is said to mean happiness but things between Jane and Lisbon will leave them truly unhappy. The only way I can see Jane and Lisbon being together is if Lisbon realizes she that she really loves Jane and wants to be with him, because I don't think Jane is going to tell her how he feels. Personally I would like to see Pike propose and Lisbon reply "Yes Patrick" or "Yes Jane" to show that she really loves and wants to be with Jane, though I doubt it will happen.