The lights go out at McKinley so the glee club goes unplugged. Ryder shares a secret with the club that only his Catfisher knows in hopes of being able to read the faces of the club members to discover the person's identity. Kitty shares a secret with Ryder.
Blaine visits Sue at her aerobics class and tells her that the Cheerios need her. Becky plans to confess to Principal Figgins just as the lights come back on.
In New York, Kurt and Rachel pressure Santana to find a path, but Isabelle tells her to take baby steps when the three of them help her with the New York Ballet Gala.