Spencer continues trying to decode the stories in Alison's diary with a little pharmaceutical help. After staying up all night, she finds out that Ali met her older love interest a college pub, The Hart and the Huntsman, and the mystery man ordered a beer and a boysenberry pie while taking to Alison about her stories. Spencer goes to the pub and sees Ezra there eating a boysenberry pie; once he leaves, the waitress brings over the beer he ordered to go with the pie, a Board Shorts Ale. Meanwhile, Hanna tries to track down an appointment sign-in sheet from Alison's dentist, but A catches her and leaves her a painful message inside one of her teeth. And A appears to be terrorizing Emily again.