Jane is tasked with finding the suspect who killed a man named Tony for his knock off watch. As Jane whittles her way down the list of suspects from his wife to a bar dishwasher, all evidence begins pointing towards Mikey the bartender.

After following Mikey and tracking his phone, on which he confesses to the murder, Louis and Auggie run and catch him in a store.

Meanwhile, Jane attends Owen’s birthday party at the request of Matt and against the wishes of Trish.