-13 year old Mandy is kidnapped by a man and woman as her little brother watches. Mandy's father is Jane's former partner, Dan.
-A young girl's body is found but it isn't Mandy. It is Sophie James who is 17 and has been missing for four years.
-Jane, Maura, and Angela try to help Mandy's brother remember details about the car that took Mandy. He draws pictures of blue cars and lighthouses. Jane realizes there was a picture of a lighthouse on the license plate.
-They track down the woman who kidnapped Mandy but she refuses to give the girl's location. She says Mandy is dead because they have angered the prophet.
-Maura and the detectives notice that both Sophie and Mandy played soccer and that their soccer photos were taken by the same photographer.
-When Rizzoli, Korsak, and Frost find his home, the man attacks them with an ax before they shoot and kill him.
-They find Mandy alive, tied up in a closet.