After 11 years Michael Scott has finally finished his movie, Threat Level Midnight. He plays it for his employees, and they all love it. It is an action movie revolving around special agent Michael Scarn. Scarn has to save the NHL All-Star Game from the evil Goldenface, who is trying to blow it up.
All of Dunder Mifflin is enjoying the cinematic work of Michael Scott. All but his girlfriend that is. Holly doesn't think it is very good, but ends up trying to apologize. Michael doesn't allow her to, and instead agrees that it isn't good, but brings her back in to finish it because the employees seem to being enjoying it.