Natalie: Don’t tell me to calm down. You ruined our fantasy.
Lou: Well, you’re ruining ours! There’s a hole in one waiting for me out there, and poor Vivian has barely had time to enjoy her tree.
Natalie: Wait. The tree? We came here for relief from the devastation of watching our entire vision of our future fall apart and you came for a tree and golf?
Lou: Don’t judge our fantasies.
Natalie: Oh, I’m not going to judge them. I’m going to destroy them.

Vivian: They still have plenty of time for kids. My tree is gone. We lost a living thing just because they wanted a watery death hole.
Lou: Some people say a watery death hole. Others say puddle of summer fun.

Anton: Princess, your beauty surpasses my imagination.
Gwen: This is wild!
Anton: I assure you, I’m quite civilized.

Elena: How are you faring?
Gwen: My handmaid has been poisoned because someone’s trying to kill me. So, other than that, I’m great.
Elena: Well, you wanted to be a princess.
Gwen: Yes, but I was thinking more like Cinderella. But anyways, high hopes dashed. Story of my life.

Princesses, they just have to smile and wave and they’re good. I could use a little of that. Also, jewels.

Gwen

[to barber-surgeon] If you don’t take [the leeches] off now and I have to, I’m going to have the king send you to the guillotine. [turns to Bea] Do we have a guillotine?

Gwen

Gwen: I used to think that being a princess would be simpler. I mean I have yet to make any decisions and everything is still wackadoodle.
Lance: Sleeping in the woods seems… not wackadoodle if it keeps you alive.

Javier: You made a decision about us without allowing me to weigh in.
Elena: I want to explain why.
Javier: No, I don’t want to hear it. Why doesn’t matter.
Elena: Javier.
Javier: Elena, if I let you explain, then I won’t be able to stay mad at you. Being mad is how I’m going to get through this.
Elena: Maybe this is wrong.
Javier: Don’t do that. You made your decision. You hurt me. My decision is to not let you do it again.

I just… I just don’t know what to do with my life, and I’m tired of thinking about it, and it’s just too much pressure.

Gwen

Gwen: I envy your talent and your skill. I don’t have either.
Lance: But you possess the ability to save a life. It’s far more impressive. I disappear into art when I can barely face my own life.
Gwen: I understand that.

Elena: Stay away from Ruby.
Isla: You’re just like your great-uncle.
Elena: I certainly hope so.

Helene: Y’know, I wasn’t born in mourning.
Javier: I know. I also know you can’t be in mourning forever.
Helene: That was a different person. That person thought she was going to go to school and live a completely normal life. Definitely did not have ‘Magical Island’ on her bingo card.

Fantasy Island Quotes

Every fantasy runs its natural course and your's has just begun.

Elena

On Fantasy Island, you’ll find it’s best to meet people where they’re at without judgment.

Elena