How I Met Your Mother Review: Was It Gouda For You?

at . Comments

How I Met Your Mother was back with a new episode this week, as the gang was all a buzz at Lily and Marshall's house warming party.

Well before the first guest arrived, Lily and Marshall sat her dad down to implore him not to wreck all the hard work she put into preparing their big event. Mickey's foray into apiculture was a real bee in Lily's bonnet, but also showed a funny parallel between her father and Marshall.

Mickey's bee puns were rather reminiscent of Marshall's fish name routine from "Old King Clancy." What seemed to be a similarity in senses of humor was yet another example of how women tend to marry men like their fathers and vice versa, as we saw how alike Lily and Marshall's mother were last season around the time Marvin Sr. passed away.

Arguing with Marshall's Boss

For a half-hour episode, primarily consisting of a series of interlinked events that unfolded within a five-minute window of time, "The Burning Beekeeper" was filled with the brand of scenes and dialogue fans of the show have coveted all season long. This is not to say we have been denied such up until now, but tonight's installment was superbly scripted and will no doubt go down as one of the most memorable of the season - if not the entire series. 

I'm sure there were those naysayers who would have admonished Lily for even thinking about throwing such a big party while fully pregnant, while others may have been critical of Marshall for being so self-involved with his work issues that he did little to take some pressure off his wife's back, but don't forget these are the Eriksens we're talking about here.

Lily was very excited about the cheese she purchased on the Internet and Marshall did his part to spread the word about the inbound hors d'oeuvres, such as when he told Ted "don't slept on the gouda." They always have each other's back. 

Barney, despite a belly full of vegan spring rolls, dug deep into his bag of aliases and pulled out Secret Agent Gary Powers, famed CIA U-2 spy plane pilot. He may have been out of his flight gear, but was nonetheless suited up and slaying it with Hung's Rebecca Creskoff, the cat-crazy, cheese knife-wielding divorcee. 

It's not often you see Barney upstaged, but when it does occur, more than not it's Robin who seems to take the spotlight. Tonight was arguably one of those episodes as she shared memorable scenes with Marshall, Barney and Ted. She brought the "Ha" with outbursts like the one about the Thin Mint-less Girl Scout, but also delivered the "Aw" moment when she and Ted put an end to their dispute and complimented each other's unique personality traits. 

Now don't get me wrong, nobody puts Barney in the corner, no matter how great a performance they might deliver. Case in point: this week's funniest line came from none other than "Jack Package" telling Robin about the gender of men's junk. I must have rewound the part where he said "come on Robin, it's my penis we're talkin' about" 20 times, each time laughing harder than the last. I highly recommend trying it at home if you have the episode recorded. 

Some of my other favorite moments included, the Sun Tzu misquotes, Robin's anger over the absence of spicy mustard for the pigs in a blanket and Mickey warning her about standing in his snack track. Also amazing was the reason behind Ted and Robin's fight. Robin yelling at the old woman while she fought for the last Zabar's kugel reminded me of when Jerry Seinfeld stole the Schnitzer's marble rye from the elderly woman.  

I'll cut myself off here as I am very eager to hear if you all enjoyed the episode as much as I did. Be sure to check out the memorable quotes list, too, as there were plenty to commit to memory. 


Editor Rating: 5.0 / 5.0
  • 5.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.4 / 5.0 (193 Votes)

Surprised at the amount of negative comments o.O. I on the contrary enjoyed this episode since for me this episode brought some classic HIMYM story telling. The seperate rooms at 5.00 mins apart was classic HIMYM.
Nice showdown between Garrison Cootes and Ted..that was hilarious. Agree with the review. A solid episode.


dont you all get the feeling that this season nothing has happened and we are as far away from seeing the mother as we were at the end of last season.....i mean nothing constructive to the future of the group , it has become too past centric..with no relation to the future of ted and group...for eg. ...goin into minute details of things that are inconsequential to the plot of the sitcom.....


the show is awful, just drags on and on, please do something funny.


Agree with everyone else... this was a terrible episode. I honestly hit the fast forward button because it seemed to just DRAAAAG on. :( Also don't get how any of this episode related to how Ted met the children's mother?!


Terrible episode! Nothing was gained! I thought the marshall story was going to go somewhere like finding out his dream job isnt really what he wants or something?, but I gave that plot too much credit since he and his bosses disput was easily resolved, Robin and teds fight was not funny or true to the character's We've never seen Robin lash out for no reason or ted to be dismissive on how he feels, Lily getting over whelmed with the arrival of the baby was predictable and short? And barney was sorta funny? but the forgettable kind


This was the very first episode where I was wishing that it would just finish!!; I thought it kept on dragging on; Usually HIMYM is amazing with these kinds of episodes but it was a little awkward to watch because it wasn't funny! I gotta say I'm really disappointed; "Best episode of the series"??!! Sorry but I totally disagree!! Probably the worst!


I do not get how Lily's dinner party relates to Ted finding his dream woman. Yeah, it was funny in my opinion, but in all it was a filler episode.


The episodes that are being aired this season are undoubtedly funny! Perhaps they should change the name of the show to How I Forced My Children To Sit Through A Story About My Friends! Honestly when do I get to see the mother? Or rather does their mother even exist is the question I want an answer to at this point! Its getting draggy and I'm not liking Teds wife search plot being side lined. I would have stopped watching the show if the title wasn't so misleading!


I loved this episode. So many things made me laugh... I don't know why so many people are hating on this episode...


This reminds me of an overenthusiastic 1st year cinema student who is so keen to use every trick in his book that he forgets that the final goal is to make a good film.
Horrible episode. Barely cracked a smile to my face.

Tags: ,

How I Met Your Mother Season 7 Episode 15 Quotes

For God's sake Lily, you're pregnant! For God's sake Ted, Lily's pregnant!


Your breath reeks of shredded carrots and deceit.