Doctor Who Review: Always

by at . Comments

They are really trying to pile on the mystery within the stories of Doctor Who Season 7 and "Hide" was no exception. It was a really fun ride if you're a fan of ghost stories, and I admit they've always been a favorite of mine.

At first it appeared as if they just swung the TARDIS by the 1970s so we could enjoy the groovy decor and ponder why a hot professor would have purchased a lonely mansion on the moors, while being attended to by an assistant whose charms seemed to be lost on him. Tsk tsk tsk. We should all know better than that by now!

Doctor Who Season 7 Scene

The setup to discover just what the ghost was and seeing cold rooms and The Doctor and Clara have frightened moments was just pure entertainment. It was also a lot more heart pounding, since I am actually afraid of things that go bump in the night, than the attempt they made with Skaldak to scare me in "Cold War" last week. Give me a haunted manor vs a claustrophobic submarine and the former wins every time.

I loved Clara's reaction to witnessing the birth and the death of earth before eyes within the TARDIS. It was a really interesting sideline to the ghost story of the Woman in the Well. It wasn't that they were there to just solve a story and move on, but to give Clara an even larger impression of being a part of The Doctor's world. It was beyond her capacity to understand. She couldn't grasp that The Doctor could see in the flash of an eye anyone and everyone....Always. She realized that everyone was, at some point, dead to him. They were all ghosts. She even said, "To you, we're all ghosts." To which he replied, "No, you're the only mystery worth solving."

Again the question of Clara being a mystery to The Doctor, which seems to be the running theme throughout the second half of Series 7 and heading into the 50th Anniversary of Doctor Who. Last week during "Cold War" commenters wondered if Clara singing "Hungry Like the Wolf" was another link to her and Rose. It's certain that The Doctor thinks Clara is liked to something or someone, but whether it's Rose remains to be seen.

Once the mystery of the Woman in the Well was solved as a person lost in a parallel dimension and The Doctor had to fight his way past some ugly tree branch looking crawfish like creature to get back to their dimension, it seemed everything was complete. The survivor couldn't go back to her own time because it would break some space timey wimey rule, but The Doctor had sussed it out that she was actually the great (many greats) granddaughter of the Professor and Emma, and that's why the connection was so strong between she and Emma. 

Thematically, love as all through the episode and it wasn't just the professor and Emma at play. The Doctor had his arm around Clara as he realized that the creature he encountered in the other dimension wasn't trying to hurt him, but to hitch a ride to back to his love:

The Doctor: Since then they've been yearning for each other across time and space, across dimensions. This isn't a ghost story. This is a love story. Sorry. | permalink

Which brought up the theory that The Doctor believes he and Clara have a special connection with which he is being just too damned cautious with us, his loving audience. You see, he didn't take the case at the Caliburn House to look into the ghost at all, but to get a chance for Emma to meet Clara so she could "read" her for him. Unless Emma was being coy and covering up a story she wished for him to find on his own, I don't believe she found anything out of the ordinary with Clara at all. After all she went through to finally get through to her own love, she would probably have told him, if only to keep Clara from getting hurt.

So to the naked eye of a powerful psychic, there is nothing undue about Clara Oswald. She's a little more scared than she lets on. But The Doctor seems so sure she is someone that he has been searching for through many dimensions. Something tells me she predates Rose, River Song and anyone we have ever known about. Perhaps a piece of her has been within all of these souls, but is culminating in Clara, across space and time just in time for the 50th anniversary.

Wouldn't that be a hoot?

TV Fanatics Love Prime Instant Video
Amazon Prime Instant Video
Catch Up on Old Episodes
of Similar Shows and Old Favorites.


Editor Rating: 4.6 / 5.0
  • 4.6 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.4 / 5.0 (44 Votes)

Carissa Pavlica is the managing editor and staff writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter and on Google+.

Tags: ,

theres actually a theory that clara represents the show itself. there's a whole thing that takes into account all her timey wimey gaps and stuff.
great episode


My wife thinks Clara is the daughter of a previous incarnation of the Doctor.
I think she is his mother, died at birth therefore not in his "lifetime".


The mystery of Clara has a familiar feeling but I can't place why. Which leads me to believe it is obvious,so obvious that I am missing it. @whatesTooMuch, I too am wrapped up in Orphan Black.


Orphan Black is getting a bit wobbly as the number of clones climbs and more of them begin impersonating others. Still, it's nice to see the story advancing, and it looks like the next episode will be a really big leap forward. It's great to watch a show that has a lot of cool secrets but doesn't take forever to let you in on them.


@Carissa: "I loved Clara's reaction to witnessing the birth and the death of earth before eyes within the TARDIS." Her reaction was rubbish. It didn't follow from the action. Maybe if we had seen a time lapse of humanity and life flowering and then fading away as in the 1960s version of "The Time Machine," it would make sense. Here, it was just an excuse to get the doctor to tell her that she's the only mystery worth solving. And although Clara heard the Doctor to be saying that humanity was the only mystery worth solving, we know he really means her, and while that's totally consistent with what we learned in "The Snowmen," it's still kinda creepy. That said, this was the best episode since "The Snowmen." The guest stars were excellent, and the story and its rhythm were much more solid than the last couple of weeks. There's plenty to quibble about, but I'm happy to see an improvement.


'Hide' was good. It'd be better if the monster plot was cut.

Doctor Who Season 7 Episode 10 Quotes

Whiskey is the eleventh most disgusting thing ever invented.


Clara: Doctor.
Doctor: Yes?
Clara: I may be a teeny tiny bit terrified.