Thursdays 8:00 PM on NBC
Community

Community Review: Gas Leak Year

by at .  Updated at . Comments

Out of all of 2013's many gripping love stories (Bey and Jay, Kim and Kanye, Adam Levine and whatever model happened to walk by him on the street that morning), the most engrossing for me, personally, was the tortured tale of Dan Harmon's reconciliation with NBC.

Fiery Community Scene

Both parties spent the past year denouncing each other like spurned lovers straight out of a Harlequin paperback, so their eventual reconciliation (and that Chevy Chase cameo!) was almost enough to make me believe in love again.

Two soul mates, reunited against incredible odds! And we didn't even have to wait for a decade and a Kickstarter campaign to make it happen!

Like all love stories, the tale of Dan Harmon and NBC's reconciliation needed a villain - and, as is clear after just a few minutes into Community Season 5 Episode 1, that villain is definitely Community Season 4 (a.k.a. the "gas leak year," as noted in one of the episode's many sharp, thrilling, and totally tossed-off Community quotes) and those who got behind it.

I was one of those villains, defending the 'Franken-Community' at times last season. And there was some logic to that decision - the Greendale 7 (or however many we're down to now) are such snappy, vibrant characters, played by such insanely talented comedic actors, that even a weakly written Community has its pleasures; it can outpace the best episode of many limper network comedies.

But moments into this season premiere, the difference between a Harmon-helmed Community and a Harmon-less Community stood out like the difference between slow-roasted artisanal coffee and Sanka (Sanka that had also been trod upon by a lost family of elk, searching for fresh grazing pastures).

I had been fooling myself. There's no faking something this genuine, this high-velocity, this weird, and I was wrong to accept any substitutes. Welcome home, Community.

The new season of Community is, thus far, brutally funny and also pretty damned brutal - from Jeff Winger's failure as a legitimate lawyer, to everyone's similarly bleak post-Greendale trajectories (Relaxarex!), to Community Season 5 Episode 2's assertion that Greendale's teachers, just like Greendale's students, are there because they completely failed their adult lives.

The show has always pulled no punches about the bleakness of the gang's lives (and life in general), but the darkness was especially notable in these two half hours, with only a few dim sources of real hope. Just like real life!

This double-barreled season premiere event was definitely not crafted to reel in new viewers. Episode 1 unspooled at break-neck pace, breaking down the various failures that have befallen our beloved former Human Beings, and unveiling Jeff's morally ambiguous legal scheming, at dizzying speed. It was poised, hilarious, and probably made as much sense as a set of poorly-translated air conditioner repair manual to non-fans.

Episode 2 offered more potential entry points for newbies, with Breaking Bad's Jonathan Banks as a very Mike Ehrmantrout-like criminology professor, and Danny Pudi doing some truly stand-out work on Abed's Nicolas Cage-induced breakdown (if we have a common American culture at all right now, it's probably at least 35% composed of Nicolas Cage movies).

But it was still an in-joke-laden affair aimed at the insider, the fan who has spent more moments than he/ she/ they/I would like to admit dreaming of this moment, and not concerned with viewers who might wonder why people with community college degrees would all be so eager to re-enroll in community college.

But Community is not here, as they say, to make friends. Community has lived through one of the most improbable (and highly publicly visible) dramas of any network show in recent memory - and, even more improbably, it has arrived back on our televisions for another season.

At this rate, "six season and a movie" would hardly be the most far-out thing that this show has achieved. So I look forward to a season filled with darkness, pain, and jokes about Van Damme. When you come back to life, you get to do it on your own terms.

Was this season premiere everything you've been waiting for? Do you dig Jeff as a teacher? Do you kind of want to take that Nicolas Cage class?

Review

Editor Rating: 4.8 / 5.0
  • 4.8 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.5 / 5.0 (78 Votes)
Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Community?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

Sarah-silva

Personally I really enjoyed these 2 episodes, I laughed a lot! My fave part was when Troy was talking about Zach Braff, leaving Scrubs.

Avatar

I missed the characters, and Community makes me smile. Enough said.

Avatar

I really enjoyed season 4 even as I lamented the departure of the creation that had originally captured me. Seasons 1-3 were phenomenal, and I fully expected season 4 to be markedly different and more than a little awkward. I think a lot of people killed it by looking for any difference and seizing a hold of it. I think that others found the season's self awareness off putting given that it was new show runners being "self aware" of someone else... The gas leak year was a huge step backwards, and it did warp the characters that I had already loved for three seasons. Knowing that was the likely price of a fourth season, I decided to engage it on its own terms. I didn't judge it based on what it used to be. I didn't judge it based on what it desperately wanted to be. I judged it based on what it was. It was hardly a rousing success, but it was still an often witty caricature that made me smile even when it didn't make me laugh. After all, October 19th (and season 4) is really a state of mind.

Avatar

It's so great to have the *real* Community back! It felt weird, so much as changed. But much better than season 4, which I call "The Stepford Students." Britta never voted? Come on. I agree, season 4 had some good moments, but they always seemed to ruin it with something sledgehammery, like Britta saying she never voted, or the idea that they were all at the same tiny frozen yogurt shop at the same time when they decided to go to Greendale.

Community Season 5 Episode 1 Quotes

Dean Pelton here, wishing you another magic year at Greendale--ranked America's #2 community college by GreendaleCommunityCollege.com.

Dean

Repo man: Maybe you should have spent less money on special effects.
Jeff: Thanks a lot, Francis Ford Repo Man.

x Close Ad