Jules forgets to pay her bills after switching to paperless billing. After hitting a man’s car, Sam, looking for her ring with lapsed insurance, Jules agrees to get a cup of coffee with him. Jules pretends to really in to him. Back at home, Jules tells everyone about it, and Grayson is happy she figured out a way to not have to pay for it. Later, Jules heads to work where she finds Sam waiting for her. He asks Jules to marry him with a flashmob. Jules agrees. At the engagement party, Jules tries to break up with him, but Grayson does it for her by saying he's been in love with her the entire time.

Elsewhere, Ellie tries to get to the bottom of Laurie's stories and Bobby looks forward to snow in Florida.