The Captain contacts Ted after a run in at an art gallery. Ted is worried it is about a recent rebound relationship he had. Both Ted and Robin remember the night differently, but Lily is the only one who actually describes the night's events accurately. Barney feels left out and tries to convince the gang he was there too. The Captain asks Lily to be his art consultant despite her admitting she stole something of his.
Ted: That's weird, I have a message.
Marshall: That's weird, you still have an answering machine.
- Permalink: That's weird, I have a message. That's weird, you still have a...
Ted: Oh boy that was a crazy story.
Barney: Oh boy, yeah I remember.
Ted: You weren't there.
Barney: Ted, bubala, if you have a crazy story, I was there. It's just the law of the universe.
- Permalink: Oh boy that was a crazy story. Oh boy, yeah I remember. You...