Hanna and Spencer try to set up a trap for A by replacing Garrett's note with one of their own. As Hanna waits around at the church (where an inconvenient dance is taking place), Spencer teams up with Jason to find April Rose. Jason discovers that April Rose is an antique store, and when the two visit the store, Spencer finds Ali's missing anklet. The police find two types of blood on the anklet, Ali's and an unknown party. This new evidence helps Garrett's case get dismissed. Meanwhile, Emily begins to remember parts of her lost evening. She recalls being at a diner with a man sporting a mysterious stamp on his wrist. When she joins Hanna at the church dance, she sees Holden there with the same stamp on his hand. Before she can get too much information about the club where he got the stamp, he leaves. Hanna waits in the church for A, but only Wilden shows up because he was given the note by a nurse. Also, Aria finds a lot of cash in Ezra's sock drawer. She asks him about it, but Ezra tells her he sold his grandfather's old car for cash since he doesn't have any money.