Spencer works on the A team, getting the girls to show up for a fake welcome back party where they will be confronted by the girl in the red coat. But, she also uses Mona's lair to track down Toby, and he tells he was only working for the A-team to keep her safe. Meanwhile, Spencer schemes to get Hanna to figure out that she was the one who kidnapped Malcolm and took him to the puppet show. Once the girls confront her, she tells them that they are going to set a trap of their own for Mona and Red Coat. Plans go awry (of course) and the girls and Mona are trapped in a burning house while Spencer tracks Red Coat through the woods. Red Coat saves Mona, Hanna, Emily and Aria by pulling them out of the fire, leaving both Mona and Hanna swearing that Allison was the girl in the red coat. When the girls return home, they find Wilden's car, pulled up from the lake. In watching the video of Ashley hitting Wilden, they see Shana and Jenna helping Wilden. They also make a shocking discovery in the trunk, which isn't revealed to the audience.