The Secret Circle > The Secret Circle Review: Who Died? > Comments Page 2
Is that for real? I mean... did they really kill off one of the Circle? Ok, it's definitely shocking, but... WHAT? I didn't see that one coming. Especially in the fifth episode. To be honest, I didn't expect any major character to die so soon. After I finished watching I was like: "but he's not really dead... right?". What does that mean for the Circle?
All in all - very good episode. I will miss Nick. Btw, I do hope that writers won't leave us with just one guy :)
@anna I have to disagree I think Gale Harold (a.k.a Charles) is totally HOT! I don't think however that Natashat Henstridge is hot enough for him. Also I think Thomas Dekker is totally hot and I love his gorgeous eyes. Yes i'll agree that it does look like his wearing make-up but I think it might just be his long eyelashes or maybe it's make-up he is a male witch for crying out loud maybe he is going for the goth/punk/emo look? Either way I love it and think it's sexy! As for last nights episode and the demise of Nick I am having mixed feelings about I was shocked that is for sure but I'm not so sure I am upset about it I mean yeah a character is gona for good but I didn't really know too much about him except he seemed to be good in bed according to the post sex scenes he had with Melissa.
@verybookish EEW.. do you seriously think Charles is hot? His hair sucks..remind's me of Elijah's in TVD but he was hotter..anyway..I loved this episode! I can't believe Nick's gone, I felt a bit sorry for Charles but I still hate him for killing Cassie's mom. What I don't get is that if ihe had to kill her to get Cassie to come so that the circle could be full how will their magic work now..especially now hat the circle is bound. Will the have to find another full witch..I guess.. Oh and I loved that grandma's in on it and I LOVED the Adam and Diana scene..she's way hotter than Cassie! I just hate the casting for Adam! He's so not leading guy material..it looks like he wears mascara!
Damn. They pulled a TVD and I'm pissed but I'm not. I didn't see it coming. I was holding on til the last seconds where they would show that somehow Nick survived but he didn't, and I was shocked. I'm pissed because he never got a chance to develop, in fact the most growth he's shown had been in this episode ironically enough. Just enough to get invested in his character and then...he's dead. But hats off to them, because yeah, it was shocking, and great writing because it was the reality check for the viewers and theother characters. They aren't afraid to kill off a main character, like in TVD and in Lost. Anyone can be a casualty to a greater plot. I just started liking hs character and now he's gone. That was intense. Couple that with the WTF?! Awesomeness of TVD and that was one hell of a night of tv.
I am glad that they brought Cassie's grandmom in on it.She definitely knows more then she lets on. I don't care for Dawn. I hate the fact that she's maniupulative. She may have the
LOVED this episode.
Loved the scenes between Charles and Dawn. Gale Harold has the most incredibly expressive face, and he was amazing in this episode, filled with remorse after killing Nick, even though we've seen him kill before (and he didn't show any remorse then).
Loved Jessica Parker Kennedy's ability to go back and forth from Melissa to demon in an instant. She gave an amazing performance, and the physicality of it was really impressive.
Loved the scene between Diana and Adam. Diana has been my favorite of the girls from the beginning, and in this episode she really brought the sex appeal.
Sorry to see Nick get killed. He was very cute - especially shirtless - but it made for an amazing episode.
How is it that Dawn acts like Charles isn't worth dating? She's a high school principle and mother in a small town. There can't even be many available guys her age, and Charles is HOT, a lawyer, has a boat, also has a kid, oh, and he's SO AMAZINGLY HOT. HOW IS SHE NOT ALL OVER
honestly the fact that they killed nick is completely asinine and i'm angry...at first i was all sad but now that i read the interview with the producer i'm just mad because nick had so much potential and to kill him off so quickly wit basically little character development JUST for shock value? wow just no
i hate that they killed nick and i hope they bring him back to life later in the season.
I guess you can call me a book purist because I did not like the fact that Nick died! He better be coming back because he is a core part of the book series.
I for one absolutely loved the fact they killed Nick. Not that I didn't like his character, but because it shows the Secret Circle is like its TVD brethren: it has balls. It's not afraid to kill off main characters and totally shock audiences.
I cannot wait to see where this surprisingly dark show takes us this season!
Nick's brother is obviously a witch/warlock too.... i think they'll have to bind the circle again.... 6 witches of 6 families.... so DUH!
I cannot believe the killed Nick, I actually liked him
Did anyone else get a Vicki flashback when Nick died?
I feel like they would bring him back to life bc that's kind of the whole show...6 Completing the Circle. How can they have a series with an incomplete circle?
I thought the episode was great! I liked Nick, but I also think killing him off was brilliant writing. I imagine someone will come along to make up for his absence in one way or another. I agree that they are in need of male witches here to balance out the show. Personally, I would've rather seen Melissa die. She seems like the most un-interesting witch in the circle and we would've been left with a 3-2 ratio.
I enjoyed the Adam/Diana escapades, but I'm still a fan of Cadam.
I can't wait to see where this show goes from here. I am completely hooked. I love the characters and the writing. As a huge VD fan, I think this show is keeping pace.
So soon? Poor Melisa!!! :(
The thing now, is that as the circle WAS bounded, we can say that now is BROKEN!!! like it has a hole or sthg...
Just when I was starting to like Nick...
Vexed. I am very vexed. If it wasn't for the hope that they'd bring him back to life somehow, I'd be done with this. I might still be done with this. If by episode five, my two favorite characters are the two with the least lines, and if in episode five they kill one of those two... What's the point, really?
Its kind of hard on secret circle to follow such an action packed VD but gotta remember the series is just starting of.
I am appreciating the diana/adam whipped cream juncture - agree with you that it has to be a believable triangle.
so now Nick's secret bro is gonna turn up or what?
Nick is dead and the show got worse, it's like girl's club now with Adam being the only guy and four girls!!! please!!! I liked Nick way more than i ever liked Adam, he walks around with that Kind and understand expression on his face and every once in a while he tries looking sexy in the face when he is around Cassie, the guy looks gay to me, and i know gays, i lots of friends that i gays. i don't have anything against a gay guy playing straight but he has to make it believable like Matthew Bomer in the White Collar!!!
shoking. i liked nick and i expected him to be there longer. it was a great episode but noooooooo nick!!!!! diana adam scene was great, love it. everything was great except for nick death :(((( TOO EARLY
@Dr.CerrenoMD: Sorry to confirm, but we'll be posting an interview later today: He's dead.
didn't watched the episode but WOW(OMG)! Nick gone! I don't think so! Brit spoiled before 2-3 days that there is going to be some major Nassie storyline! Probably a little bad ghost will come along!
2. We don't know if Nick has any relatives? Maybe it will be some new bad boy!
3. Where is Mel's Mom(Dad)? Should've someone look out for her! Cause Cassie is back! Many questions!
What the hell? Why the hell would kevin williamson et al KILL Nick? Seriously? I am freakin shocked to the core! This is insane insane insane! Seriously! My word! I don't think he is dead. There has to be something they can do. I don't believe that. Kill someone at the end of the season not in the fifth ep. My gosh!
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info