The Vampire Diaries Round Table: "1912" Comments (Page 2)
31 Comments
melena
March 17th, 2012 12:43 PM
Damon was such an ASSHOLE in this episode. I hate him
Sa'ad702 Rank: Regular Character
March 17th, 2012 8:56 AM
1. The scene when they find out about Alaric. I was literally tingling in excitement towards the end.
2. A very clever and interesting twist to the story.
3. Sage. I like Cassidy more than Ariel. She is an amazing actress and has roots that goes all the way back to the originals. I def want to know her history with Finn.
4. Meredith actually being good especially from the start of the ep when it seemed that she was the evil one. As for Matt, I think that he and Elena should end up together.
5. It needs to flashback to 900 years ago and we need to see the back story between Sage, Finn and Rebekah. Its the most obvious choice. I am thinking she was probably the first vampire to be created after the originals. Should be an interesting story.
nasne
March 17th, 2012 4:31 AM
@ Jasmine you should read better. The phrase is: The team of (names) is here. The 'is' refers to the team, not the individual names.
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Either Stefan and Damon's cute scene or all of Damon's hilarious jokes.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
Unpredictable, but underwhelming. They could have done it better, I didn't like Meredith's involvement.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
HAHA Matt, but even though she was on 90210, still Lexi. I wanted to like Sage since she's more involved with Damon, but I just couldn't.
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Stefan gets crazy around blood, so no. It was too obvious to be Meredith. So hands down Matt. Does anyone remember S1's Matt? He was the stupidest guy around! I didn't know he could read let alone pick a lock. Well done Matt!
Lexi was definetly cooler than Sage. First off I don't like Cassdiy Freeman I didn't like her on Smallville and I could care less about her on TVD. I don't think she is pretty at all she kinda looks like a bug in my opinion. Definetly not pretty enough for Damon.
Jasmine
March 16th, 2012 11:48 PM
I would love to be the editor for tvfanatic.
In the paragraph: What did you think of the trip back to 1912 and the events we witnessed in the present day? As always, our Round Table team of Matt Richenthal, Steve Marsi, Dan Forcella and Eric Hochberger is here to break down all the action. Won't you join in?
Shouldn't it be 'are' here to break down all the action.
JLO
March 16th, 2012 10:47 PM
Sorry but this show was boring, no surprises except for the Matt/Elena moments. Elena and Stefan's relationship is what drew me to the show but now it just seems to be getting worse each week. Don't care about Klaus and Rebecca, too much killing and not enough of a good storyline. I wish the writers would focus on normal issues with the characters and not all of this blood and gore. The show is going down hill in my opinion. Tired of all the brother bonding scenes. Sweet at first but now it's just too extreme. Poor Alaric...I guess he'll be killed of the show soon. Don't like Meredith. Season 1 has been the best thus far.
fortyseven Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 8:35 PM
1. Can't decide
2. Cool
3. Lexi. Sage has been disappointing do far.
4. Decapitation
5. 1994. Matt and Elena playing in a sandbox.
Blu Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 7:38 PM
- Damon. He was excellent this episode with everybody. I mostly enjoyed his time with his brother though. He was honestly and genuinely showing love and trying to help his little brother. That's what this show thrives,the most important relationship of the series.
- Once I finally realized what was going on (still don't know if I fully know honestly) I was intrigued. I like Alaric.
- Lexi. She was like Caroline except cooler.
- Meredith not being shady. Only because I still don't buy it and still don't trust her. The others weren't surprising. Matt 's been awesome playing therapist for awhile now.
-60's because I'd like to see the historical aspect...wonder if they'd avoid the civil rights movement like they avoid slavery? And 80's. That's just good times and great costumes.
Fruit Salad
March 16th, 2012 7:35 PM
@Spindae How could they make a flashforward? They have no idea what they're gonna do next, they're just riding along. Kinda charming, don't ya think? All that incoherency and plot holes really makes me feel like anything's possible, because hey, you know, screw logic.
But if you mean like a prophecy or more Bonnie dreams I suppose that would be cool... but still, I doubt the writers would be able to live up to it.
Spindae Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 5:48 PM
5.NewFlashbackEra!
-For a change I would make a flashforward! Just some glimps so they can twist the story in a different way!
Spindae Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 5:41 PM
1.-have to agree with Matt!Amazing scene!Tension and emotion! and the damon-stefan bounding scene! wOw
2.-Torrey is an amazing actress!And her part in this story was great! She rocked it!I love the story! But I don't want it to be an exit story!But one is aksing me! :(
3.-I love Lexie!She is amazing and she posses the screen in the moment she appears!Sage is pure game!Never knowing what she is thinking!
4.-enjoyed him in his first scene with Elena!He deserves a lot better that the writers give him!he is a decent actor but he need some edge! Human can be kick ass!
LOVED this ep cause it wasn't rushed and forced as the last one!more about the characters not about spells!
Amie Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 4:14 PM
To what era should the show flashback to next?
Well, my icon says it all, THE 70'S! Would love to see the brothers getting all boogie to "Don't blame it on the sunshine, don't blame it on the moonlight...blame it on the boogie!".
Amie Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 4:13 PM
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Stefan and Damon's scene with Damon's decision to be there for Stefan. It was really a great scene Salvatore brothers scene because for once it wasn't about Elena.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
I found the twist that it all relates to the ring more interesting than actually finding out Alaric was the one doing the killings. I like it when those little details have the main impact.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
Lexi for sure, I haven't seen her in s1 cos back then I wasn't into TVD, but once I saw how she smashed Stefan's head into the car's window...I would ask her to teach that! Plus she has amazing style!
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
The girl's head falling off was enough to make Stefan become the Rippah
Favourite scene - Damon and Stefan heart-to-heart. Especially the part when Damon said this: "Whenever you go too far, I will be there to pull you back. Every second, every day. Until you don’t need me."
I'm just gonna say it. That scene broke my heart. There is nothing I love more than the Salvatore brothers. Their relationship is absolutely the best thing on this show. It has been since day one.
As for the whole "Alaric going crazy" thing - I totally did not see that coming. Ric killed Caroline's dad! And then stabbed himself! Can things get MORE messed up?
Sage vs Lexi - Lexi all the way.
Come on guys, Matt has been helpful before. The Ripper scene was pretty intense, but we knew that was his way. I lost track of Meredith's actions a long time ago. Make up your mind, woman! You want to shoot Ric and throw him in jail or help him? You don't get to do both!
Lalalala Rank: Guest Star
March 16th, 2012 3:54 PM
I'm sorry, I may be crazy, but I don't think Alaric is the killer. I didn't watch the paleyfest thing, so I'm not sure if it was really confirmed or not, but from what I read, they didn't. I don't know, there was something about the way he said he was invisible...
Vampbarbie Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 3:53 PM
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Well I new Meredith wasn't the killer. That would be to obvious. Matt still has no SL. He's just there to take up space it seems. So I guess Stefan tearing the girls head off. They keep recycling Stefan's blood control SL!
To what era should the show flashback to next?
They should quit with the flashbacks for a while. You don't need to do a flashback everytime you talk about the past or introduce a new villain.
Vampbarbie Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 3:51 PM
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
When Caroline was trying to help Bonnie with her mothers transition into a vampire and Abby was being out of control! Oh wait that never happened! Another off screen SL I would of liked to see. So much for Bonnie having a SL in the show this season that we get to see.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
I guess it's good that's theres consequnces for chearting death so much. But how are humans to suppose to have any advantage now with fighting these super strong fast vampires.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
Matt: I'd say Lexi. But then she showed up on 90210 and I lost all respect for her.
Lexi made more of impact in 30 seconds of appearance then Sage for her 5 to 7 minutes.
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
To what era should the show flashback to next?
ENOUGH with flashbacks. TVD excelled in flashbacking in Season one, but by now, they do more BAD than good to the quality of the writing in the show and are used mostly to either retcon stuff or needlessly fill episode up to the full amount of ~40 minutes.
Pretty much all of S3 flashbacks have been plain uninspired and dull.
Show, you are not lost, you are not btvs, you are not angel, you are not once upon a time. Those shows actually have great writers and top-notch quality writing. With TVD I am beginning suspect that there's a whole room full of monkeys with typewriters writing episode plots now.
By now TVD feels like a 14 year old child trying to replicate S.Dali's paintings. Grats for great wishes for the heights, but you just don't have the needed skill in writing.
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Fourth episode in row, no scene stood out. A worrying sign.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
I am surprised that someone actually thought it was "unpredictable" they have been quite ham-handed on pointing to Alaric through the season and generally its just a pointless twist in order to FINALLY(FINALLY!) write out the damn plot-armor rings out of the story somehow...two seasons too late.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
Lexi hands down. Sage, just like Melissa(refusing to call her meredith still, because she is NOT), was yet another uninspired cardboard-ish prop introduced into story. Ultimately a VERY pointless role.
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Neither. First two were pretty much, well, obvious and the th
leila
March 16th, 2012 3:42 PM
Favourite scene:
Easy choose - "Whenever you go to far i`ll be there to pull you back. Every second, every day. Until you don`t need me." - "Why" - "Because right now you`re all i got" - PERFECT - Standing ovations to the writers..
Alacric twist:
Perfect - but it left me sad for everyone including the audience in front of the tv. I`m happy that Matt get his own show..But i will miss him and Damon together like hell..
Sage or Lexi:
Easy choice - LEXI. Sage is bad stuff..
Next flashback:
The 70`s. Matt said something hilarios at the Paleyfest. What if Damon killed Jim Morrison? lol..And Paul said why didn`t w do it like Forrest Gump. Flashing back all milestones of history and there will allways be a Salvatore behind..lol
Elena : I just want to kill her. It's that simple.
March 17th, 2012 12:43 PM
Damon was such an ASSHOLE in this episode. I hate him
Rank: Regular Character
March 17th, 2012 8:56 AM
1. The scene when they find out about Alaric. I was literally tingling in excitement towards the end.
2. A very clever and interesting twist to the story.
3. Sage. I like Cassidy more than Ariel. She is an amazing actress and has roots that goes all the way back to the originals. I def want to know her history with Finn.
4. Meredith actually being good especially from the start of the ep when it seemed that she was the evil one. As for Matt, I think that he and Elena should end up together.
5. It needs to flashback to 900 years ago and we need to see the back story between Sage, Finn and Rebekah. Its the most obvious choice. I am thinking she was probably the first vampire to be created after the originals. Should be an interesting story.
March 17th, 2012 4:31 AM
@ Jasmine you should read better. The phrase is: The team of (names) is here. The 'is' refers to the team, not the individual names.
Rank: Extra
March 17th, 2012 1:19 AM
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Either Stefan and Damon's cute scene or all of Damon's hilarious jokes.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
Unpredictable, but underwhelming. They could have done it better, I didn't like Meredith's involvement.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
HAHA Matt, but even though she was on 90210, still Lexi. I wanted to like Sage since she's more involved with Damon, but I just couldn't.
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Stefan gets crazy around blood, so no. It was too obvious to be Meredith. So hands down Matt. Does anyone remember S1's Matt? He was the stupidest guy around! I didn't know he could read let alone pick a lock. Well done Matt!
Rank: Guest Star
March 17th, 2012 12:54 AM
Lexi was definetly cooler than Sage. First off I don't like Cassdiy Freeman I didn't like her on Smallville and I could care less about her on TVD. I don't think she is pretty at all she kinda looks like a bug in my opinion. Definetly not pretty enough for Damon.
March 16th, 2012 11:48 PM
I would love to be the editor for tvfanatic.
In the paragraph: What did you think of the trip back to 1912 and the events we witnessed in the present day? As always, our Round Table team of Matt Richenthal, Steve Marsi, Dan Forcella and Eric Hochberger is here to break down all the action. Won't you join in?
Shouldn't it be 'are' here to break down all the action.
March 16th, 2012 10:47 PM
Sorry but this show was boring, no surprises except for the Matt/Elena moments. Elena and Stefan's relationship is what drew me to the show but now it just seems to be getting worse each week. Don't care about Klaus and Rebecca, too much killing and not enough of a good storyline. I wish the writers would focus on normal issues with the characters and not all of this blood and gore. The show is going down hill in my opinion. Tired of all the brother bonding scenes. Sweet at first but now it's just too extreme. Poor Alaric...I guess he'll be killed of the show soon. Don't like Meredith. Season 1 has been the best thus far.
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 8:35 PM
1. Can't decide
2. Cool
3. Lexi. Sage has been disappointing do far.
4. Decapitation
5. 1994. Matt and Elena playing in a sandbox.
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 7:38 PM
- Damon. He was excellent this episode with everybody. I mostly enjoyed his time with his brother though. He was honestly and genuinely showing love and trying to help his little brother. That's what this show thrives,the most important relationship of the series.
- Once I finally realized what was going on (still don't know if I fully know honestly) I was intrigued. I like Alaric.
- Lexi. She was like Caroline except cooler.
- Meredith not being shady. Only because I still don't buy it and still don't trust her. The others weren't surprising. Matt 's been awesome playing therapist for awhile now.
-60's because I'd like to see the historical aspect...wonder if they'd avoid the civil rights movement like they avoid slavery? And 80's. That's just good times and great costumes.
March 16th, 2012 7:35 PM
@Spindae How could they make a flashforward? They have no idea what they're gonna do next, they're just riding along. Kinda charming, don't ya think? All that incoherency and plot holes really makes me feel like anything's possible, because hey, you know, screw logic.
But if you mean like a prophecy or more Bonnie dreams I suppose that would be cool... but still, I doubt the writers would be able to live up to it.
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 5:48 PM
5.NewFlashbackEra!
-For a change I would make a flashforward! Just some glimps so they can twist the story in a different way!
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 5:41 PM
1.-have to agree with Matt!Amazing scene!Tension and emotion! and the damon-stefan bounding scene! wOw
2.-Torrey is an amazing actress!And her part in this story was great! She rocked it!I love the story! But I don't want it to be an exit story!But one is aksing me! :(
3.-I love Lexie!She is amazing and she posses the screen in the moment she appears!Sage is pure game!Never knowing what she is thinking!
4.-enjoyed him in his first scene with Elena!He deserves a lot better that the writers give him!he is a decent actor but he need some edge! Human can be kick ass!
LOVED this ep cause it wasn't rushed and forced as the last one!more about the characters not about spells!
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 4:14 PM
To what era should the show flashback to next?
Well, my icon says it all, THE 70'S! Would love to see the brothers getting all boogie to "Don't blame it on the sunshine, don't blame it on the moonlight...blame it on the boogie!".
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 4:13 PM
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Stefan and Damon's scene with Damon's decision to be there for Stefan. It was really a great scene Salvatore brothers scene because for once it wasn't about Elena.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
I found the twist that it all relates to the ring more interesting than actually finding out Alaric was the one doing the killings. I like it when those little details have the main impact.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
Lexi for sure, I haven't seen her in s1 cos back then I wasn't into TVD, but once I saw how she smashed Stefan's head into the car's window...I would ask her to teach that! Plus she has amazing style!
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
The girl's head falling off was enough to make Stefan become the Rippah
Rank: Guest Star
March 16th, 2012 4:06 PM
Favourite scene - Damon and Stefan heart-to-heart. Especially the part when Damon said this: "Whenever you go too far, I will be there to pull you back. Every second, every day. Until you don’t need me."
I'm just gonna say it. That scene broke my heart. There is nothing I love more than the Salvatore brothers. Their relationship is absolutely the best thing on this show. It has been since day one.
As for the whole "Alaric going crazy" thing - I totally did not see that coming. Ric killed Caroline's dad! And then stabbed himself! Can things get MORE messed up?
Sage vs Lexi - Lexi all the way.
Come on guys, Matt has been helpful before. The Ripper scene was pretty intense, but we knew that was his way. I lost track of Meredith's actions a long time ago. Make up your mind, woman! You want to shoot Ric and throw him in jail or help him? You don't get to do both!
Rank: Guest Star
March 16th, 2012 3:54 PM
I'm sorry, I may be crazy, but I don't think Alaric is the killer. I didn't watch the paleyfest thing, so I'm not sure if it was really confirmed or not, but from what I read, they didn't. I don't know, there was something about the way he said he was invisible...
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 3:53 PM
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Well I new Meredith wasn't the killer. That would be to obvious. Matt still has no SL. He's just there to take up space it seems. So I guess Stefan tearing the girls head off. They keep recycling Stefan's blood control SL!
To what era should the show flashback to next?
They should quit with the flashbacks for a while. You don't need to do a flashback everytime you talk about the past or introduce a new villain.
Rank: Regular Character
March 16th, 2012 3:51 PM
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
When Caroline was trying to help Bonnie with her mothers transition into a vampire and Abby was being out of control! Oh wait that never happened! Another off screen SL I would of liked to see. So much for Bonnie having a SL in the show this season that we get to see.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
I guess it's good that's theres consequnces for chearting death so much. But how are humans to suppose to have any advantage now with fighting these super strong fast vampires.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
Matt: I'd say Lexi. But then she showed up on 90210 and I lost all respect for her.
Lexi made more of impact in 30 seconds of appearance then Sage for her 5 to 7 minutes.
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Well I new Meredith wa
March 16th, 2012 3:50 PM
To what era should the show flashback to next?
ENOUGH with flashbacks. TVD excelled in flashbacking in Season one, but by now, they do more BAD than good to the quality of the writing in the show and are used mostly to either retcon stuff or needlessly fill episode up to the full amount of ~40 minutes.
Pretty much all of S3 flashbacks have been plain uninspired and dull.
Show, you are not lost, you are not btvs, you are not angel, you are not once upon a time. Those shows actually have great writers and top-notch quality writing. With TVD I am beginning suspect that there's a whole room full of monkeys with typewriters writing episode plots now.
By now TVD feels like a 14 year old child trying to replicate S.Dali's paintings. Grats for great wishes for the heights, but you just don't have the needed skill in writing.
March 16th, 2012 3:46 PM
What was your favorite scene from the episode?
Fourth episode in row, no scene stood out. A worrying sign.
What did you think of the Alaric twist?
I am surprised that someone actually thought it was "unpredictable" they have been quite ham-handed on pointing to Alaric through the season and generally its just a pointless twist in order to FINALLY(FINALLY!) write out the damn plot-armor rings out of the story somehow...two seasons too late.
Sage or Lexi: Which vampire from the Salvatore brothers' past would you rather... hang out with?
Lexi hands down. Sage, just like Melissa(refusing to call her meredith still, because she is NOT), was yet another uninspired cardboard-ish prop introduced into story. Ultimately a VERY pointless role.
More surprising development: That girl's head falling off in 1912, Meredith actually being on the side of good, or Matt playing a helpful role this week?
Neither. First two were pretty much, well, obvious and the th
March 16th, 2012 3:42 PM
Favourite scene:
Easy choose - "Whenever you go to far i`ll be there to pull you back. Every second, every day. Until you don`t need me." - "Why" - "Because right now you`re all i got" - PERFECT - Standing ovations to the writers..
Alacric twist:
Perfect - but it left me sad for everyone including the audience in front of the tv. I`m happy that Matt get his own show..But i will miss him and Damon together like hell..
Sage or Lexi:
Easy choice - LEXI. Sage is bad stuff..
Next flashback:
The 70`s. Matt said something hilarios at the Paleyfest. What if Damon killed Jim Morrison? lol..And Paul said why didn`t w do it like Forrest Gump. Flashing back all milestones of history and there will allways be a Salvatore behind..lol