Pretty Little Liars

Tuesdays 8:00 PM on ABC Family
Pretty little liars
TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

Pretty Little Liars Review: Spencer's Tainted Love

by at . Comments

Well, they can't all be winners.

After two episodes filled with exciting revelations, Pretty Little Liars slows things down with "Dead to Me." Much of tonight's focus was on Spencer's worsening downward spiral, while there was very little progress on the A-team and Ali's murder

While focusing on the characters and their lives (as the show did tonight) can add a lot of dimension and deeper significance to the events, it can also be quite contrary to the point of the series: solving the mystery. In other words, it's great for fans of the characters, but frustrating for those of us who just want some answers. 

Emily in Therapy
The most helpful revelation involved Emily and a hypnotherapy session. Emily is finally dealing with the fallout from killing Nate after receiving a French postcard from A that basically called her a murderer (and it does sound much prettier in French). As most therapists know, hypnotherapy can be tricky, especially because of the ambiguous nature of memories and memory recall.

Of course, Emily's mind conflates two memories into one. She thinks she killed Ali because of her first vision, but returning to the cemetery reminds her that the memory was actually of the night that Ali's body was stolen from her grave. Emily saw a hooded A-figure (Toby?) and a blonde in the red coat. I didn't really believe Emily could've killed Ali. Mostly cause this show loves red herrings!

We already know that Emily was with Jenna and possibly Holden (or someone with that mysterious party stamp) that night, but who did she see at the grave? Could Mona have sneaked out of Radley that early on?

Hanna finally articulated the question the rest of us were thinking: Could the girl in the red coat be Ali? They just re-interred Ali's body and said their goodbyes again, but is there more to the story of her death? With this show, the answer is definitely yes.

Emily's assertion that the girl in the red coat is probably the one in charge is something we kind of already knew. The red-coated girl has been hanging around a lot since Mona was sent away, so it makes sense that she would be the one calling the shots. In terms of Pretty Little Liars shockers, this one was weak.

Most of the episode just made me really frustrated with Spencer. #PoorSpencer may be trending, but I'm definitely not following. I feel very bad for her because she finally realized that Toby isn't who she thought he was. He probably didn't mean all the wonderful things he wrote in those cards. Because he's on the A-team!

I have sympathy for her up to a point, but why hasn't she told the girls yet?!? Instead of helping her friends protect themselves, she's moody, withdrawn and vicious. Luckily she's directing her anger at deserving subjects. Mona's crack about Spencer being "off her A-game" may serve to push her over the edge (as we saw in the promos for next week) because it definitely rubbed her the wrong way. And she's suddenly super upset with Ali.

I've never thought Ali was someone the girls should be so concerned with because she seemed like a pretty awful person, but Spencer seems to be taking it out on the wrong DiLaurentis. Telling Jason about Ali's supposed pregnancy was reckless and petty. They don't even know if it's true or if Wilden really is the father. Emily was right when she said that Spencer just wants everyone to feel her pain. When is someone finally going to confront her about her crazy behavior?

In other developments, Ezria fans might have to deal with another obstacle to a reunion for their favorite couple. Executive producer Oliver Goldstick didn't paint a rosy picture of their future, especially with Wes's appearance. There was definitely some major flirting going on, and Aria told Hanna she does think he's cute. Would a Wes-Aria couple really be such a bad thing?

Haleb fans were treated to an inordinate amount of screen time this week. I was definitely worried for Caleb while watching him avoid facing the rejection of his father's family. Caleb's family drama definitely makes him the kid of tortured teen that attracts both Hanna and Liars fans. But I would have liked to see a little more A-progress instead of spending so much time with them rummaging through boxes.

I do have one errant thought. What do you think Mona meant when she said she could never really repay Dr. Sullivan for what she did? Did the doctor do more than conveniently disappear in Pretty Little Liars Season 2?

Review

Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.2 / 5.0 (90 Votes)
Tags: ,
Avatar

I don't feel bad for Spencer. I mean, is it truly awful that Toby betrayed her liked that? Yes. Does it make it ok for her not to tell them? no. She shouldn't have said that to Jason. Also, considering Spencer always jumps to conclusion about who A is, it almost seems petty that she isn't telling the girls, like she can't admit she was wrong about Toby.

Marissa

Good episode. The most interesting thing was with Emily remembering more about the night at the cemetery. Spencer was way out of line telling Jason Allie was pregnant and that Wilden is the father because like you said we don't even know if any of that is true. I would like seeing aria and Wes together. Hannah showing Caleb the picture was the right thing to do. Can't wait till the next episode.

Avatar

I'm begging to HATE this show I need answers!!!!! I don't care about the relationships.
They are time consuming & poorly written. All I want is something different from the obvious.

Avatar

instead of being angry at spencer, like a lot of people are for some reason, i'm mad at the other girls. they're angry that spencer is lashing out but they're not really questioning why spencer, the level headed, logical one, is acting crazy? or why toby suddenly disappeared? spencer has been there for the other girls so much, and has reached out and asked them what's wrong but none of the other girls have done that, besides emily. obviously its hard for spencer to tell them that the love of her life, the person she trusted the most, has been doing this to them. but maybe she would have the courage to if she could get some support instead of being scolded when she has an outburst. she's hurting and no one's really trying to understand how or why.

Sp mckenna

I just wish Toby and his gangsta do rag would have made an appearance again

Pretty Little Liars Season 3 Episode 18 Quotes

We're your friends; we're not your punching bags.

Aria(to Spencer)

Aria: "Unable are the loved to die for love is immortality."
Hanna: That's creepy.
Aria: It's Emily Dickinson.
Hanna: I don't care if it's Santa Claus, considered me creeped.

Pretty Little Liars Season 3 Episode 18 Music

  Song Artist
Pi jacobs trying to be loved Trying To Be Loved Pi Jacobs iTunes
Bellflower without the one i love Without The One I Love Bellflower iTunes
Madi diaz burn Burn Madi Diaz iTunes
× Close Ad