Supernatural Review: Eat Your Heart Out

by at . Comments

Supernatural fans, eat your heart out.

This essentially one-off episode about organ transplants, Mayan gods and bloody beating hearts was not only directed by Jensen Ackles, Mr. Dean Winchester himself, but it even starred his father, Alan Ackles.

There was an obvious resemblance and it was clear pretty quick that Papa Ackles can hold his own against Dean. Talk about entertaining Acktion.

Dean and Dad

It's actually pretty impressive that Ackles was in so much of this episode considering that he was directing. When he first did "Weekend at Bobby's," Ackles popped in here and there, but the brunt of his presence was behind the camera. The same could certainly be said for last season's "The Girl Next Door," allowing for much of the focus to be on Sam and his past love.

Yet "Heartache" featured a lot of Dean screen time and I could tell that being the one in control allowed Ackles to do exactly what he wanted, from giving subtle facial expressions, like his eyebrow raise when Sam was raving about his favorite football player; or starting the episode off with a nice creepy tone via shots of the runners on the foggy path.

And they say that jogging is good for you. Right.

The case itself was interesting and had a pretty classic feel to it. I had no idea what was going on with the killers besides thinking maybe it was a shifter, but I liked bringing in a Mayan god ritual through the organ donors while putting some spin on a 1000-year old sports superstar.

It was even enjoyable getting the throwback about the professor helping them with the amazons now assisting them with the unknown language. That was the episode where Dean's one night stand had gone awry, remember?

I was a little disappointed in the final fight, especially in that the two organ donors seemed to have forgotten about Sam after hitting him once. Clearly at his size, Sam doesn't do a classic TV knockout.

Yet, what some fans might be groaning at, which I rather enjoyed delving into, was the continuing look at Sam and Dean's changes after one year.

Young Men in Suits

It's obvious that Dean has come back with a focused warrior mind, knowing what he has to do in order to save the world. At the same time, Sam's had a very long time to experience something he never got the chance to have when Dean showed up on his doorstep eight years ago in the pilot: a real life.

In a way, it's a lot like the brothers are retaking up their roles with which they first started the show.

So, it makes sense that Sam is the one to embrace normal life more so than when Dean did in Supernatural Season 6. Dean, as much as perhaps he thought he wanted it, was never cut out for it.

It's interesting that Sam is applying to colleges and that he openly tells Dean that he is okay with quitting after Kevin and the Demon tablet. Will he actually do it? I hope not because I'd like to see a few more seasons of Supernatural!

And while I am able to understand and acknowledge where Sam and Dean come from in their respective thought processes, the flashback that was supposed to really show Sam happy and comfortable with that life fell a little flat for me.

For whatever reason, maybe it was the heavenly glow or the line about never seeing a birthday cake before, I kept waiting for Sam to turn to the camera and start talking about some drug or medication we should take, much like he did in the episode "Changing Channels."

Maybe it seemed too happy and tonally was vastly different from the dark episode or more specifically the dark Impala in which Sam was pondering, but I couldn't help but want to laugh. It just felt a little cheesy.

I guess I'd just really like Sam's flashbacks to be as engrossing as Dean's, even if one is about fighting in Purgatory and the other supposed to be something of a sweet love story. But I do like that it wasn't overused to try and backup what Sam was thinking because his conversations and attitude conveyed it in the episode.

Although I wouldn't say it was my favorite Supernatural investigation, the hunt for the heart killers worked fine and Jensen Ackles delivered on the director's front. Now I just wonder if Jared Padalecki will be following in the director's footsteps any time soon.

What did you think of the episode and Jensen Ackles' third time in the director's chair? As always, sound off below!

TV Fanatics Love Prime Instant Video
Amazon Prime Instant Video
Catch Up on Old Episodes
of Similar Shows and Old Favorites.


Editor Rating: 4.1 / 5.0
  • 4.1 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.5 / 5.0 (124 Votes)

Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,

I think Ackles did a fine job directing. It was better than the episode he directed last year (which suffered from badly paced flashbacks), but not as good as Weekend At Bobby's, which had a better script.


The end was a little cheesy, but overall it was a good monster of the week ep. As for Dean killing it with the knife, we have to remember that all he, or Sam, had to do was stop it's heart from beating. No magic was required. So Dean killed it by stabbing it in the heart. As for Sam saying he's done hunting after the tablet story arc, thus ending the series, I wouldn't read too much into that. Both Sam and Dean have said they were giving up hunting over the years. Both Padalecki and Ackles said they want to be back for seasons 9 and 10.


I thought this episode was kinda boring.And the end fight was anti-climactic for me as well.Did Dean kill her with plain old Rubys knife ?? . . . And i agree with Sams flashback coming off a bit corny and cheesey.It reminded me of a laundrey detergent commercial lol.


But I do agree that I hope he gets over it and stay in the game. He can find a woman and hunt with her he has proven it before. Although one was a demon, but they have shown couples who were hunter. And yes one or both has die, but hey he and dean our technical a couple and they have fight both sides and came back.


I like it, and get where u are coming from about Sam, seeing as season one is playing on tnt right now. I get that they are trying to give Sam that life he miss, the thing is that Sam always fought being a hunter vs. Dean. Even when the angel wipe their mind, to see if they would still choose a life as hunter. Sam only stay in the game because he thought he have to for his brother. And at times he did, I mean when dean came back from hell, he was different, and over time he lost confident in his self. Our the will to fight and now he has it. Which make Sam more willing to leave and get on with bus life. Remember there were times when dean told him to quit, go to school, start a family.